A. E. Schlueter Pipe Organ
Company, Lithonia, Georgia
First United Methodist Church, Atlanta, Georgia
Atlanta First United Methodist Church was originally organized as Wesley Chapel in 1847, and has maintained a long tradition of excellence in worship. The present church was built in 1903, when Mr. Asa Candler purchased the former church site for the headquarters of Coca-Cola. After moving to the new location, the church changed its name to Atlanta First United Methodist Church. Many Methodist luminaries have served this congregation, including the venerable Pierce Harris.
The first pipe organ known to be installed in the church was a two-manual Roosevelt in 1885. When the present church was built, this instrument was moved. In 1919, the organ was re-actioned and rebuilt by Möller. Further changes occurred in 1953 when the organ was enlarged to 46 ranks by another firm. A new façade was built from new and existing pipes in a “pipe fence” array; while commanding in stature, the new façade did not pay homage to the architecture of the building and was poorly constructed. Fortunately, during the 1950s work, ten stops from the former Roosevelt instrument were retained; unaltered, they could be considered for inclusion in the new 2008 instrument. Over the succeeding years, the organ was rebuilt as sections failed and generally kept in working order. The organ provided the basic needs for service playing, but, quite simply, was too small for the space.
Jump forward to 2003 when senior pastor Rev. Wayne Johnson commissioned a feasibility task force to redefine the church’s mission and plan for future ministry. As with many downtown churches, the community around the church was displaced as office buildings replaced homes. Yet this church saw opportunity. The feasibility task force determined it needed to continue its television ministry, continue its education through the Candler School (founded at Atlanta FUMC, but now only affiliated through the denomination), and renovate and restore the church building. It was noted that the organ needed to be addressed as part of the building infrastructure. The task force engaged an architect to provide possibilities for the chancel renovation. J. Donald Land, director of music and organist, led the charge to consider the organ and its renovation or replacement.
A. E. Schlueter Pipe Organ Company was one of several firms interviewed for the project. We viewed this as a real opportunity to build an instrument of significance in our hometown. It is not often that an opportunity develops to build a “Magnum Opus” in the same city as a firm’s location. The Schlueter family decided that the building of this instrument was more important than simple financial gain. Trust that our pencils were very sharp because of this unique opportunity to create art. In our interview, we discussed with the committee the opportunity for an organ of multiple divisions and a wide palette of colors, in an organ case that would complement the church. Specific emphasis was placed on preserving the stewardship of the past. In our design, pipework from the two previous instruments was incorporated in the various departments of the organ.
Quality organbuilding is never the result of one individual but of the synergy of a team. In this respect, our firm was ably assisted by the Atlanta First United Methodist Church clergy, music staff, church staff, and feasibility task force. These individuals readily gave of their time and talents and provided invaluable assistance from the inception of the organ project to its installation and tonal finishing. Specifically we would like to recognize Dr. Bob Smith, chair of the feasibility task force, who was charged with the selection of the architect and organbuilder; J. Donald Land, director of music and organist; Wally Colly, church liaison; senior pastor Rev. Wayne Johnson, deceased, whose vision propelled this project forward even in his absence; and current senior pastor Dr. Jim Ellison.
As part of the building renovation, the choir loft was to be lowered (it was eight feet above the pulpit). This meant that the organ case would need to begin from a much lower plane than the actual organ chamber. We designed the lower case walls to begin below the main organ chassis and act as a reflective shell for the choir. The interior layout of the organ was designed to allow the choir to hear the organ without taking the full brunt of large registrations. In effect, the organ “blooms” just forward of the choir loft.
At the center point of the organ, the chamber is only nine feet deep, so modest cantilevers were designed into the organ case to grow the chamber space without creating a large shelf above the choir that would hamper hearing the organ. Visually, these forward pipe towers give the illusion of a more forward presence.
The engineering that developed would require the organ divisions to be stacked one on top of another. Often stacked organs rely on the division above to form the ceiling for the lower division. This is a problem because the sound speaks into windlines, reservoirs or schwimmers, organ actions, or other parts. It is also mechanically difficult to service the above division because of the sea of pipes located below it; this is often remedied by placing additional perch boards over the pipes, thus adding more impediments to sound reflection. Our solution was a careful design that built dedicated floors and ceilings in each division.
The layout of the organ finds the Swell, String and Choir divisions located on the bottom level. The Solo and Great divisions are located in the top level of the organ, with the Pedal in an open two-story chamber in the center of the case. The Great is enclosed with a ceiling that allows it to speak into the center of the case and to blend with the lower divisions in the chancel, rather than going completely over the musicians’ heads. This purposefully built chamber has proved very effective in coalescing the many divisions of the organ and eliminates geographic specificity of the individual organ stops. The rear of the church houses the Antiphonal, Antiphonal Pedal and Trompetteria divisions of the organ. The Antiphonal is situated at the same height as the Great organ, thus promoting tuning stability.
Because the church has a very active television ministry, there was a concern about the console being exposed and commanding behind the pulpit. A lift was designed that allows the console to be lowered to reduce its visual signature, and, when not needed for other church events, the console can be lowered down and rolled into a side parking location. The platform then can be raised to increase the available space in the chancel.
The console and organ case are constructed of quarter-sawn white oak. We made a conscious effort to incorporate elements of the church building into the console and organ case. Our design engineers, Howard Weaver and Robert Black, saw to it that arches, quatrefoils, and acanthus leaves became part of our vocabulary. It was clear that portions of the organ case would require large grille openings to provide maximum divisional egress into the room. We did not desire to use cloth grilles in the organ case. These impede airflow, are long-term maintenance issues, and affect sound. We designed wood grilles with an open quatrefoil pattern, which allow both the free passage of sound and airflow for tuning stability.
In designing the console, we were very concerned about the ergonomics of its layout. Those who have had the opportunity to sit at larger consoles are aware of their visual and physical challenges. To overcome some of the issues of actually reaching the playing surfaces, we foreshortened the organ sharps as the keys ascended from Manual I to Manual V. The keyboards are not sloped, but with subtle adjustment to the manual relationships even Manual V is comfortable to reach. A similar consideration was given to the pedalboard and expression shoes, which were designed using proportions normally found in our three-manual consoles. Special attention was given to the layout of the pistons, toe studs, drawknobs, and tilting tablets. The end result is that all of the controls can be used and seen without the leaning and craning about that occurs on a large console. It is a very comfortable console to play.
Some interesting facts about the organ:
• the organ contains 93 ranks with 5,360 pipes represented in nine divisions;
• in excess of 10,000 board feet of lumber were used to build this instrument;
• the organ contains over 10 miles of wiring for switching and control;
• the organ uses wind pressures that range from 3½" to 11";
• the main manual windchests are slider, with reeds on electro-pneumatic windchests;
• three divisions of the organ are located in the rear chambers;
• the Trompette en Chamade in the rear of the sanctuary is made from brass;
• the organ weighs over 44,000 lbs.;
• the front organ case stands over 43 feet tall;
• the instrument contains pipes of lead, tin, zinc, brass, and wood;
• the wind for the organ is created by three blowers;
• the organ is controlled with a five-manual console.
The tonal design of this organ was the result of many discussions. Prior to scaling this instrument, organist Don Land and I were able to visit a number of recent instruments built by our firm. Doing this in a short time frame was very helpful to determine tonally where we had gone and where we were going. Don brought in local organists Tom Alderman, David Stills and Richard Morris for their input to the specification and console layout. Tom Alderman worked as a consultant to Don. As a triumvirate, we worked through the myriad of decisions involving the final stoplist, drawknob layout, couplers, pistons, toe studs, and other controls. In the end, I recognize that I was offered a tremendous level of trust and generally an unfettered hand in the tonal design and scaling of the organ.
As the final specification became the math of scales, halving ratios, metal thickness, mouth widths, cut-ups, and languid bevels, I had the good fortune of having Daniel Angerstein and John Tanner to look over my notes. We have worked together on many projects over the years.
For tonal finishing, I was very ably assisted by a team led by Daniel Angerstein, with the assistance of John Tanner, Lee Hendricks, and Bud Taylor. I want to thank Daniel, John, Lee, and Bud for their input regarding division balance, dynamics, color, neutrality, fundament, harmonics, chiff (or lack of), treble ascendancy, and so many other factors. There must always be a final arbiter of design and direction and, in those instances where I followed a different path or tonal treatment, the civility for further discourse remained. I would like to personally single out Daniel Angerstein for his contribution to this project.
It is the daily give and take and discussion that allows art to flourish. It is a rule of organbuilding that you will not make everyone happy with your choices and decisions. The most important question is not “what will others think?” but “have I completed the work to the best of my ability and the charge or commission that I was given by my client to achieve their vision?” As a builder, it is important always to remember what the service role of the instrument will be, and that in the end, the instrument you are building is a tool for worship and is part of the church fabric. Just as your thumbprints are on the instrument, so must be the thumbprints of the church members.
On a project of this size, one challenge was keeping the organ in tune and making adjustments called for during tonal finishing. To make this happen, the voicers would work from 8 am to noon and then break. During lunch hour, members of our staff would take the opportunity to “punch-list” final items and adjustments. When the voicers returned, the room again would settle into the silence of single tones and “louder, softer, more flue, less flue,” etc. After the voicers left in the evening, the crew was again released to make adjustments until 9 pm, when the tuning crew arrived to perform the nightly vigil of preparing the organ for the voicers in the morning. Where stops required work beyond a reasonable ability to perform it in the chamber, we would prepare sample Cs and remove the stop for voicing in our shop. The completed stop would then be installed into the organ for final finishing. This ballet of work went on for weeks on end, and I wish to thank the dedicated members of my staff for the completion of this instrument and for the internal support provided from one staff member to another.
Special recognition must go to our craftsmen, Marc Conley and Robert Black, who were ever present in overseeing the design, engineering, and building of all of the myriad parts that constitute an instrument of this stature. They ensured that the final fit and finish met our standards of quality in engineering and execution. Marc served on the “sharp end of the stick” and worked untold hours at the church to see the project to its completion.
Tonally, this instrument reflects our desire to create organs that possess warmth and clarity. In this room, which promotes clarity of tone and gentle unforced voices, we found wonderful bass presence but the need for an ascendant treble. In the tonal design, all of the divisions of the organ are based on an 8' principal chorus. We differentiated these principal choruses, in addition to the vast array of flutes, strings, and mutations to allow the performance and support of many schools of repertoire. The organ was designed with numerous strings and celestes. It is an absolute joy to hear a transcription on the organ or the subtle undergirding of a choir. With the plethora of solo reeds in the organ, we were able to provide differing reed choruses in the various divisions and pure ensemble function for some of these departments. The organ has reeds designed after English, German, and French styles. The completed instrument pays homage to the important organbuilders and organbuilding styles of the past but is not a copy of any particular builder or style.
This instrument was designed to play a role in all musical styles of worship, from traditional to contemporary. To support the non-traditional role, the instrument is equipped with MIDI capability and a separate chamber audio system. This allows other tones not normally associated with the organ to be generated and controlled by the console. In this manner the organ can blend its voices with other sounds and participate in services that might normally exclude the pipe organ.
Early on, the client had discussed the inclusion of some digital voices in the organ. There was a desire for some stops in the organ that would be considered secondary or tertiary in nature and were the type of stops that might normally be drawn out of a MIDI sound module. They did desire that these stops be voiceable and individually tunable, which specifically excluded MIDI voices. In our interview, we were asked if we would consider working with Walker Technical Company in the installation of these voices. Even though the majority of our experience had been limited to 32' and 16' extensions and percussions, we were aware of the high quality of engineering and sound quality provided by Walker.
As we considered the inclusion of digital voices, the primary question was how? It is probable that, in consultation with the client, we could have left prepared-for stops in the console, to be completed by a third party without our direct involvement. In effect, the stops could have been added in a “don’t ask, don’t tell” fashion, which we considered unpalatable. I am well aware that this method of installing digital stops has allowed some firms to remain “intellectually honest,” but I consider this method to be, at best, morally untenable. If you are providing for additions to the organ in the console and relays, which forces a digital solution because the chamber, winding system, or structure could never accommodate the proposed installations, you cannot pretend you simply did not know, and worse, you have ceded part of your tonal vision to a third party. We considered that if this were the desire of the client, we would work to ensure as seamless an integration of the adjunct stops as possible and to consult on the stops and their voicing.
One fundamental concern with the inclusion of digital stops is where does one start and where does one end once the genie is “out of the bottle.” Our consideration was simple—even though there was a possibility to use digital voices, we strongly desired the organ to be able to stand on its own with the speakers and amps unplugged. There were instances where it would have been much easier to leave out that additional 16' register of pipes in lieu of a digital voice. I am proud to say we resisted this temptation and made organbuilder choices.
Bob Walker worked directly with our firm and Daniel Angerstein in voicing and tuning these stops, and we were very pleased with the final results. Where we desired the voicing and balances to be altered and changed, Mr. Walker was accommodating and worked to achieve a result in keeping with our overarching tonal philosophy for this instrument. The digital stops are as seamless as we had hoped, and the stops contribute around the periphery, as planned by the client, without overtly placing their presence on the stoplist. To the critics, I would say that our firm approached this instrument with integrity of design, and you can indeed play the organ successfully without any digital stop. There are now 93 ranks of wind-blown pipes where there were 46 ranks, and we have completed the tonal vision of our clients in a unified, cohesive manner.
In the end, how do we view this project? In truth, we are still overwhelmed by the opportunity presented to us and the fine work completed by our staff. It is as if we have been so close to the project it is difficult to see what we have done. Analytically, we are aware that the instrument is stunning to hear and see, and yet it will take time to back away far enough from the façade, console, and thousands of pipes to see and hear what others already know of this instrument.
Personally, I do know this—our firm was gifted with an opportunity to build an instrument that we could only have dreamed of at the beginning of our career. We are grateful for the trust placed in us by Atlanta First United Methodist Church and so very fortunate to have the talented and skilled staff that we enjoy. Our tonal philosophy is to “build instruments that have warmth not at the expense of clarity and clarity not at the expense of warmth.” We are thankful to have been given such a grand canvas upon which to express our tonal ideals.
In summation, I would like to thank my father and our company founder, Arthur E. Schlueter, Jr. He is the foundation upon which our company was built and continues to thrive. His continuing role as artist, mentor, and president provides the ongoing oversight of our firm. I am humbly proud to call him both Boss and Dad, as we together work to build instruments for worship.
—Arthur E. Schlueter III
A.E. Schlueter Pipe Organ Company wishes to thank its staff including:
Arthur E. Schlueter Jr., president
Arthur E. Schlueter III, vice president/tonal and artistic direction
John Tanner, vice president of production/tonal finisher
Howard Weaver, senior design engineer
Rob Black, master cabinet-maker/organ engineer
Marc Conley, production supervisor
Bud Taylor, assistant production supervisor
Shan Dalton, office manager
Bob Parris, executive assistant
Barbara Sedlacek, office support
Mike Norris, woodshop foreman
Tony DiLeo, console builder
Bob Black, BSME, mechanical engineer
Joe Sedlacek, console wiring
Jeffery Chilcutt, CAD operator
Michael DeSimone, leathering and assembly
Dustin Carlisle, organ assembly
Sam Polk, organ assembly, tuning assistant
Kelvin Cheatham, organ assembly
Wilson Luna, assembly and wiring
Norma Renteria, leathering, assembly and wiring
Rockshawn Owens, organ assembly
Ruth Lopez, leathering and assembly
Kevin Cartwright, tuning & tonal assistant
Bob Weaver, leathering, assembly, tuning and service
Othel Liles, electrical engineer
Patty Conley, relay wiring
Herb Ridgely, Jr., sales & support
Mike Ray, electronics technician
David Stills, sales & support
Rick Stewart, sales & support
Dave Kocsis, program manager
The cover photo is by Michael Mitchell of Creative Expressions. Other photo credits as indicated.
GREAT (Manual II, unenclosed)
32' Contre Bourdon (Pedal)
16' Bourdon (Pedal)
16' Violone 73 pipes
8' First Open Diapason 61 pipes
8' Second Open Diapason 61 pipes
8' Violone (ext)
8' Harmonic Flute 49 pipes
(common bass from Rohrflote)
8' Rohrflote 73 pipes
5-1/3' Gross Quint 61 notes+
4' Octave 61 pipes
4' Prestant 61 pipes
4' Rohr Flute (ext)
3-1/5' Gross Tierce 61 notes+
2-2/3' Twelfth 61 pipes
2' Super Octave 61 pipes
2' Waldflote 61 pipes
2-2/3' Cornet III 183 notes+
1-1/3' Fourniture V 305 pipes
2/3' Scharf IV 244 pipes
16' Contra Trompete 85 notes+
8' Trompete (ext)
4' Clarion (ext)
16' Trombone (Solo)
8' Tromba (Solo)
8' Festival Trumpet (Solo)
Tremulant
Chimes (enclosed with Solo)
Cymbalstern
Great to Great 4'
MIDI on Great A
MIDI on Great B
SWELL (Manual III, enclosed)
16' Lieblich Gedeckt 73 pipes
8' Violin Diapason 61 pipes
8' Traverse Flute 61 notes+
8' Stopped Flute (ext)
8' Viola de Gambe 61 pipes
8' Viola Celeste 49 pipes
8' Viol Dolce Celeste II 122 notes+
8' Flute Celeste II 122 notes+
4' Prestant 61 pipes
4' Harmonic Flute 61 pipes
4' Unda Maris Celeste II 122 notes+
2-2/3' Nazard 61 pipes
2' Flageolet 61 pipes
1-3/5' Tierce 61 pipes
2' Plein Jeu Grave IV–VI 330 pipes
2/3' Plein Jeu Acuta III–IV 208 pipes
16' Bombarde 61 notes+
16' Contre Fagotto 85 pipes
8' Trompette 73 pipes
8' Oboe 61 notes+
8' Vox Humana 61 notes+
4' Clarion (ext 8')
4' Fagotto Clarion (ext 16') 24 pipes
Tremulant
Swell to Swell 16'
Swell Unison Off
Swell to Swell 4'
MIDI on Swell A
MIDI on Swell B
STRING ORGAN
(Manual III, enclosed with Swell)
16' Viol Celeste II 122 notes+
8' Viol d’Orchestra 61 notes+
8' Viol Celeste Sharp 61 notes+
8' Viol Celeste Flat 61 notes+
8' Dulcet Celeste II 122 notes+
4' Violina Celeste II 122 notes+
4' Dulcet Celeste II 122 notes+
8' Vox Mystique 61 notes+
Tremulant
String Unison Off
CHOIR (Manual I, enclosed)
16' Quintaton 61 notes+
8' Weit Principal 61 pipes
8' Voce Umana 61 notes+
8' Bourdon 61 pipes
8' Gemshorn 61 pipes
8' Gemshorn Celeste 49 pipes
8' Unda Maris II 122 notes+
4' Principal 61 pipes
4' Nachthorn 61 pipes
2-2/3' Nasat 61 pipes
2' Wald Flute 61 pipes
1-1/7' Septieme 61 notes+
1-3/5' Terz 61 pipes
1-1/3/ Quint 61 pipes
1' Sifflote 61 pipes
8/9' None 61 notes+
2' Choral Mixture IV 244 pipes
1/2' Terz-Cymbal III–IV 208 pipes
16' Corno di Bassetto 61 notes+
8' Clarinet 61 pipes
16' Dulzian 61 notes+
8' Holzregal 61 notes+
4' Rohr Schalmei 61 notes+
8' Tromba (Solo)
8' Harp 73 notes+
4' Celesta (ext)
Tremulant
Choir to Choir 16'
Choir Unison Off
Choir to Choir 4'
MIDI on Choir/Pos A
MIDI on Choir/Pos B
ANTIPHONAL (Manual I, enclosed)
16' Bourdon 97 pipes
8' Principal 61 notes+
8' Gamba 61 pipes
8' Salicional 61 pipes
8' Voix Celeste 49 pipes
8' Gedeckt (ext)
8' Flute Celeste II 122 pipes
4' Principal 61 pipes
4' Harmonic Flute 61 pipes
2-2/3' Nazard (ext 16')
2' Blockflote (ext 16')
2' Mixture IV 244 pipes
16' Contre Trumpet 61 notes+
8' Harmonic Trumpet 61 pipes
8' Flugel Horn 61 pipes
Tremulant
Antiphonal to Antiphonal 16'
Antiphonal Unison Off
Antiphonal to Antiphonal 4'
SOLO (Manual IV, enclosed)
8' Major Open Diapason 61 notes+
8' Violincello 61 pipes
8' Violincello Celeste 49 pipes
8' Doppelflote 61 pipes
8' Flauto Mirabilis 61 notes+
4' Claribel Flute 61 pipes
4' Eclat V 305 notes+
8' Tromba 61 pipes
8' English Horn 61 pipes
8' Harmonic Trumpet 61 pipes
8' Festival Trumpet 61 notes+
8' French Horn 61 notes+
16' Tuba Magna 73 notes+
8' Tuba Mirabilis (ext 16')+
4' Tuba Clarion (ext 16')+
Tremulant
Solo to Solo 16'
Solo Unison Off
Solo to Solo 4'
MIDI on Solo A
MIDI on Solo B
TROMPETTERIA
(Manual V, enclosed with Antiphonal in gallery)
8' Tuba Mirabilis (Solo)
16' State Trumpet 85 notes+
8' State Trumpet (ext)+
4' State Trumpet (ext)+
2' Tierce Mixture V 305 notes+
16' Trompette en Chamade TC
8' Trompette en Chamade 61 pipes
4' Trompette en Chamade 49 notes
PEDAL (unenclosed)
32' Contre Diapason 32 notes+
32' Contre Bourdon 32 notes+
32' Contre Violone 32 notes+
16' Principal 44 pipes
16' Wood Open 32 notes+
16' Violone (Great)
16' Bourdon 44 pipes
16' Lieblich Gedeckt (Swell)
16' Quintaton (Choir)
8' Octave (ext 16')
8' Violone (Great)
8' Bourdon (ext 16')
8' Gedeckt (Swell)
4' Choralbass 32 pipes
4' Nachthorn 32 pipes
4' Rohr Flute (Great)
2' Octavin 32 pipes
2-2/3' Mixture V 160 pipes
32' Contre Bombarde 32 notes+
32' Contre Basson 32 notes+
16' Ophicleide 32 notes+
16' Trombone 12 pipes
16' Bombarde (Swell)
16' Contre Fagotto (Swell)
16' Corno di Bassetto (Choir)
8' Festival Trumpet (Solo)
8' Bombarde (ext 32')
8' Tromba (Solo)
4' Clarion (Solo)
4' Clarinet (Choir)
MIDI on Pedal A
MIDI on Pedal B
ANTIPHONAL PEDAL (enclosed)
32' Echo Bourdon 32 notes+
16' Principal 32 notes+
16' Bourdon (Antiphonal)
8' Octave 32 notes+
8' Gedeckt (Antiphonal)
16' Contre Trompette (Antiphonal)
+ Walker stops
Coupler Rail
Great to Pedal 8, 4
Swell to Pedal 8, 4
Choir to Pedal 8, 4
String to Pedal 8
Antiphonal to Pedal 8
Trompetteria to Pedal 8
Solo on Pedal (couplers follow through)
Swell to Great 16, 8, 4
Choir to Great 16, 8, 4
String to Great 8
Antiphonal to Great 16, 8, 4
Trompetteria to Great 8
Solo on Great (couplers follow through)
Swell to Choir 16, 8, 4
String to Choir 8
Antiphonal to Choir 8
Trompetteria to Choir 8
Solo on Choir (couplers follow through)
Antiphonal to Swell 16, 8, 4
Trompetteria to Swell, 8
String on Solo 8 (couplers follow through)
Trompetteria to Solo 8