Skip to main content

Harpsichord News

by Larry Palmer
Default

On August 15, Sante Fe harpsichordist Virginia Mackie joins the very exclusive club of centenarian harpsichordists; indeed, the only other one known to me is retired Paris Conservatoire Professor Marcelle de Lacour, who turned one hundred on November 6, 1996, celebrating the event by playing a recital for the residents of her retirement home!

 

After earning her BA at Wellesley College (Phi Beta Kappa), Mrs. Mackie did her Master's work at Columbia University, and spent several summers in France studying with Nadia Boulanger. Her teaching career in music theory and performance took her to Kansas City Junior College (as head of the music department), Yale University, and to the University of Missouri at Kansas City (where she served as Haag Distinguished Professor of Music). When UMKC later conferred on her its first honorary doctorate given to a woman, in lieu of an acceptance speech Mrs. Mackie gave an acceptance harpsichord recital, as well as a series of master classes.

Following a stint at the University of Arizona, Mrs. Mackie moved to Sante Fe, where she has been designated a "Santa Fe Living Treasure." Here she continues to share her keen analytical skills and love of music with a small number of students. She is especially devoted to the music of Haydn, and, of course, to the masterworks of J.S. Bach, who, I am certain, is happy to share the kudos of his own high-profile year with such a distinguished colleague.

Thanks to Dr. Charles Mize for providing information used in this report.

Women, Men, and Harpsichords in Colorado

More than fifty registrants assembled in Boulder, Colorado, for the Midwestern Historical Keyboard Society's 16th annual meeting, May 18-20. Subtitled "A Conference in Early Music," program chair Theresa Bogard's agenda was much more than that, for it included Elaine Funaro's fascinating program of 20th-century harpsichord music by women (ranging from Wanda Landowska, 1951, through Sondra Clark, 1999), Susanne Skyrm's premiere of composer Sarah Dawson's new work for fortepiano, Dumuzi's Dream, and my own illustrated talk on Swiss patroness Antoinette Vischer's many avant garde harpsichord commissions. Denver resident Hal Haney, venerable editor of The Harpsichord, spoke about some of his experiences while interviewing major and minor figures of the harpsichord revival during the journal's years of publication, 1968-1976.

The conference theme was well served by two evening recitals: supremely communicative soprano Julianne Baird presented a concert of music from author Jane Austen's music collection, elegantly partnered by fortepianist Theresa Bogard, the program heightened by readings from Austen's novels presented by Baird's husband and the highly expressive Marion Paton. The closing concert, presented by Cecilia's Circle (Janet Youngdahl, soprano; Julie Andrijeski, baroque violin; Vivian Montgomery, harpsichord; and Julie Elhard, viola da gamba), consisted of a series of lovely excerpts from the music of Barbara Strozzi and Elizabeth Jacquet de la Guerre.

The conference opened with Elizabeth Farr playing all six of J.S. Bach's Trio Sonatas on her Keith Hill pedal harpsichord. Fleet fingered and footed, she dealt ably with a sticking pedal note, but as a program, this seemed to me rather like reading an encyclopedia; I lasted only through volumes A-L, the first three.

Novel scholarly presentations were given by Arthur Haas (suggesting that François Couperin's second Ordre for harpsichord might be a tribute to Elizabeth Jacquet de la Guerre); Catherine Gordon-Seifert (similarities between some melodic models in Louis Couperin's allemandes and those in the mid-17th-century French serious air); and Martha Novak Clinkscale (Women's Role in the Piano Business of the late 18th and early 19th centuries). Edward Kottick paid a sly tribute to John Barnes' tongue-in-cheek take on Italian harpsichords, in his paper "The ‘Specious Uniformity' of 18th-Century German Harpsichords."

Instruments by Thomas Bailey, Dana Ciul, Thomas Ciul, Douglas Maple, Peter O'Donnell, and Ted Robertson were demonstrated by Nanette Lunde and Max Yount, former presidents of MHKS. At the group's annual business meeting, Lilian Pruett, retiring editor of The Early Keyboard Journal (jointly published by SEHKS and MHKS) was honored for her twenty years of service; Carol Henry Bates was welcomed as the new editor.

Cool, sunny, and springlike, Boulder's weather was ideal, allowing inspiring views of snow-capped mountains. Social events, especially the evening receptions, provided good food and the all-important times to share talk with friends and colleagues.

Related Content

Four Centuries of Great Keyboard Instruments:

Vermillion, South Dakota

Larry Palmer

Larry Palmer is a contributing editor for The Diapason.

Default

In an historic first for the United States, three regional
early keyboard societies (Southeastern, Midwestern, and Western) met for a
joint conference ("Four Centuries of Great Keyboard Instruments: What
They Tell Us") at the National Music Museum, Vermillion, South Dakota,
May 16-19. Gratifying as it was to participate in this possible first
step toward a national organization, the main attraction of the Vermillion
gathering was the Museum and its superb collection of historic musical
instruments.

150 registrants overfilled the concert venue named for
Museum founder Arne Larson, and the group often spilled from the tearoom into
hallways for breakfast and coffee breaks. Still, the capable and welcoming
staff were able to overcame most difficulties and make all feel
welcome--sometimes rather warmly so! From an elegant buffet reception at
the home of University of South Dakota President Jim Abbott to the closing
party at program co-chair John Koster's rural retreat, physical hungers
and thirsts of the crowd were well served. All other meals, included in the
modest registration fee, were taken together in the University's Coyote
Student Center. Communal dining, a feature of previous gatherings in
Vermillion, was an appreciated convenience in this small Midwestern college
town.

A recital capped each jam-packed day. Two of these proved to
be especially fortuitous partnerships between artist and instrument. Closing
the conference, Andrew Willis played his aptly-chosen program on an
early-19th-century Viennese piano by Anton Martin Thÿm. For the first half
he chose works by Moscheles, Field, Hummel, and the rarely-performed Sonata
in E minor
, opus 70 of Carl Maria von
Weber. Following intermission Willis gave transcendent performances of
Schubert's
Moments Musicaux
(the fifth, in F minor, will never sound right again without the piano's
Turkish percussion effects) and Beethoven's
E Major Sonata
style='font-style:normal'>, opus 109, perhaps the musical highpoint of the
conference. Among several visiting European artists, Miklós
Spányi stood out for his effortless musicality and consistently
interesting playing in a program of sonatas by Johann Eckard, C. P. E. Bach,
and Joseph Haydn, performed on the colorful Spath & Schmahl 1784
Tangentenflügel (using the correct spelling of Spath, without its
ubiquitous umlaut, as discussed by Michael Latcham in an illuminating lecture
on this instrument and its maker).

A concert by Tilman Skowroneck (earnest performances of
works by Louis and François Couperin and Rameau) introduced the resonant
1785 Jacques Germain harpsichord. Luisa Morales gave straightforward readings
of Iberian sonatas, allowing only two of them to be heard on the wiry and
virile José Calisto Portuguese harpsichord of 1780, and playing far too
many more on a beefy 1798 Joseph Kirckman double harpsichord, utilizing the
kaleidoscopic possibilities for registrations available on this instrument.
Morales was joined by Spanish folk dancer Cristóbal Salvador for her two
concluding Scarlatti sonatas, after which Salvador led a post-concert dance
class for those brave enough to participate.

The conference schedule listed an additional (and
overwhelming) 32 lectures or short performances! This attendee, for one, found
it impossible to attend all of them, especially those given late in the afternoons.
style="mso-spacerun: yes"> 

Some memorable programs included: 

* A deeply moving clavichord recital of Bach preludes
and fugues, played by wounded warrior Harvey Hinshaw, who had tripped while
loading his instrument late at night for the trip to Vermillion. Fortunately
neither Harvey nor his fine Lyndon Taylor clavichord sustained permanent
damage, although each showed bruises from the unfortunate altercation.

* Carol lei Breckenridge's Mozart played on two
clavichords from the Museum's collection: a 1770 Swedish instrument and
an 1804 Johann Paul Kraemer & Sons, built in Göttingen.

Three consecutive Sunday afternoon programs dealt with
repertoire from the now-historic 20th century, as well as some new works of the
fledgling 21st:

* Larry Palmer spoke about Herbert Howells' Lambert's
Clavichord, the first published clavichord music of the revival period.
Recorded examples played on clavichord, harpsichord, and piano served as
illustrations. Inferior sound equipment forced an impromptu performance of the
first clavichord example on the Wolf harpsichord.

* Attractively garbed in gold happy coat,
Berkeley-based Sheli Nan presented some of her own harpsichord compositions,
complete with video camera to record her every gesture.

* Calvert Johnson, with understated virtuosity, presented
a superb concert of harpsichord music by Japanese women composers Makiko
Asaoka, Karen Tanaka, and Asako Hirabayashi (now there is a focused
specialization!) on the Museum's 1994 Thomas & Barbara Wolf
harpsichord, an instrument tonally modeled on the Germain instrument, but
tastefully decorated in sober black and red with gold bands, rather than the
18th-century instrument's unfortunate color scheme of raspberry pink and
ultramarine, with a gratuitous 20th-century "French bordello" lid
painting

The original Germain, an exceptionally fine-sounding
instrument, was the most utilized harpsichord of the conference. It was heard
in programs played by Elaine Thornburgh, Paul Boehnke, Nancy Metzger, Nanette
Lunde, and Jillon Stoppels Dupree, who proved to be a passionate advocate for
the far too little-known music of Belgian composer Joseph-Hector Fiocco.

A smaller gem, the Museum's recently-acquired Johann
Heinrich Silbermann spinet (Strasbourg, 1785) was heard in performances by Paul
Boehnke and Asako Hirabayashi.

The "home team" of faculty members from the
University of South Dakota made major contributions:

* Piano professor (and program co-chair) Susanne Skyrm
played appropriate music on the soft, clavichord-like piano by Manuel
Antunes  (Lisbon, 1767) as well as
a much-appreciated traversal ("from the sublime to the ridiculous,"
she noted) of music by Beethoven (three Bagatelles
style='font-style:normal'>), Vorisek, and Herz. This program concluded with the
bellicose
Siege of Tripoli: An Historical Naval Sonata
style='font-style:normal'> by Benjamin Carr, for which Professor Skyrm employed
all the "Drums, Bells, and Whistles" available on the Thÿm
piano. Her partner in hilarity was handkerchief-waving narrator, Dr. Matthew
Hardon.

* Organ professor Larry Schou demonstrated the fine
six-stop organ by Christian Dieffenbach (Pennsylvania, 1808) as well as the
1786 Josef Loosser house organ from the Toggenburg Valley of Switzerland.

Virtuoso lectures included:

* Peggy Baird's slide presentation showing
keyboards in a wide variety of paintings ("Music for the Eye and Art for
the Ear"), delivered with her usual irrepressible wit.

* Ed Kottick's informative and entertaining
"Tales of the Master Builders," amusing vignettes from his
just-published book A History of the Harpsichord (Indiana University Press).
Hermann [Pohl] the Hapless, indeed!

* Sandra Soderlund's well-organized, informative
talk on Muzio Clementi, enriched by musical examples played on a square piano
by John Broadwood, London, circa 1829.

San Francisco's Laurette Goldberg invented some
Goldberg Variants on harpsichord history in an amazing after-dinner ramble
following a memorable vegetable, chicken, or beef Wellington banquet on Monday
evening.

Throughout the meeting several instrument makers displayed
examples of their work. Among these a French double harpsichord by Knight
Vernon featured a splendidly light action; Paul Irvin's 1992 unfretted
clavichord produced a generous volume of sound; and Owen Daly's
Vaudry-copy harpsichord delighted these ears and fingers, as did finely crafted
instruments by Robert Hicks and Douglas Maple.

During her first visit to the United States in the early
1960s, harpsichordist Isolde Ahlgrimm was especially amused by the ubiquitous
pink flamingo representations she saw in many suburban front yards. It was with
a sense of recurring cultural history that my eyes were captivated by the colorful
pink bird statue displayed at the Museum's visitors' desk, visible
through the windows of the Larson Concert Hall. Closer inspection showed it to
be a hand drum, dubbed the "Flabonga," a gift to Museum Director
André Larson.

Because of unavoidable travel difficulties, papers by David
Chung (Hong Kong) and Eva Badura-Skoda (Vienna) were read by Museum staffers.

So what did these examples from four centuries of great
keyboard instruments have to teach us? For this listener they reinforced, once
again, that most music sounds better, and far more interesting, when played on
period instruments tuned in appropriate temperaments. They underscored how vast
the variety of historic keyboards is. They showed how comparatively
monochromatic a tonal range the contemporary piano presents, and how
impoverished it is by its paucity of coloristic devices such as modulators,
bassoon stops, bare wood (or variously-covered) hammers, and Janissary
percussion.

Keyboards from Vermillion's National Music Museum
(formerly known as The Shrine to Music) demonstrated that informed restoration
and constant care permits them to function as superb instruments for music.
Curator John Koster announced early in the proceedings that keeping 1588
strings in tune for the weekend would be a major task! He managed it with grace
and skill, as he did his many other responsibilities during the conference.

It was encouraging to note a number of other visitors to the
Museum during our time there. Many of them were young students, a group
distinctly, and disturbingly, not well represented on the rosters of our
keyboard societies. I would urge each reader to plan a visit to this
outstanding American museum, and, if possible, to make this collection of early
keyboard instruments known to a student. A virtual visit to these holdings is
available through the Museum's website: <www.usd.edu/smm&gt;.

A Grand Meeting: MHKS in Grand Rapids

Larry Palmer

Larry Palmer is harpsichord editor of THE DIAPASON.

Default

Two concerts featuring harpsichordists Skip Sempé and Olivier Fortin provided ample reason for making the trip to Michigan's Grand Valley State University to attend the 2004 annual meeting of the Midwestern Historical Keyboard Society. Slightly fewer than 50 members did just that from May 20-22; they were rewarded with a carefully calibrated schedule of events, beautifully organized and efficiently administered by program chair and host, Grand Valley State's University Organist Gregory Crowell.

The opening duo-harpsichord recital featured an all-French program comprising works by Chambonnières, Lully, le Roux, and François Couperin, symmetrically framed by six compositions of Jean-Philippe Rameau: a keyboard transcription of Air pour les esclaves africains from his opera Les Indes Galantes, and five individual movements from the Pièces de claveçin en concerts. These included an especially arresting performance of La Forqueray, one full of verve, agogic surprises, and unexpected accelerandi, all contributing to a characterization of the gambist-composer more willful than usually encountered, but fully in keeping with Sempé's reputation for innovative interpretations. Displaying a splendid partnership, the duo drew rich sounds from two harpsichords by Douglas Maple, optimally heard in the resonant acoustic of the University's Cook Dewitt Center--a high, narrow white plaster hall with a wall of glass windows affording a view of tall trees and spring greenery.

For the closing concert the harpsichordists were joined by violinist Olivier Brault and gambists Susie Naper and Margaret Little from Sempé's ensembles Capriccio Stravagante and Les Voix Humaines in works by Buxtehude (Sonata in G, opus 1/2 and two overly-fleet organ works transcribed for two harpsichords, Ciaccona in e and Passacaglia in d); Schenk (Ciacona in A and a Sonate for two violas da gamba); Biber (the virtuoso Passacaglia for solo violin); Kühnel; Reinken (Bach's transcription of an Adagio from his Hortus Musicus, additionally transcribed for two harpsichords); and a culminating Germanic "hoedown," the exhilarating Fechstschule [Fencing School] by Johann Schmelzer, replacing a second Buxtehude Sonata listed in the program.

The meeting's topic, Music of the Netherlands and Scandinavia, gave focus to the well-paced events of Friday and Saturday. Judith Conrad, in gentle affirmation of Greg Crowell's rhetorical query "What could be better than to begin a morning with clavichord music?," opened the morning events with her well-chosen and lovingly played program of post-Reformation music from the Baltic trade routes, performed on her new triple-fretted clavichord by Andreas Hermert of Berlin (based on a Swedish instrument of 1688). At the harpsichord Helen Skuggedal Reed presented Buxtehude's dance suite on the chorale Auf meinen lieben Gott (BuxWV 179), convincingly relating its five movements to the five stanzas of the chorale, as both words and music progressed from darkness to light. Asako Hirabayashi followed with a program of unfamiliar Swedish harpsichord music by Gustav Düben (a dance suite), Johann Agrell (whose Sonata IV began well with a virtuoso, Scarlattian Allegro, but became less interesting in the succeeding three movements), and Hinrich Philip Johnsen (Sonata V), with its expressive Adagio sensitively rendered.

The day's first violent thunderstorm pummeled the roof of the recital hall, making it a challenge to hear all of John Koster's informative illustrated lecture on harpsichord making in the Low Countries before and after Ruckers. We all appreciated the forethought of the planners, however, when all was dry enough for open-air enjoyment of Julianne Vanden Wyngaard's carillon concert, graciously played for the group shortly before she was scheduled to leave for another recital in Washington, DC.

Calvert Johnson gave a useful introductory talk on English and Dutch psalm accompaniments for congregational singing, a topic taken further both practically and lustily in the evening program, a Genevan Psalter Sing, with organists Pamela Ruiter-Feenstra and Christiaan Teeuwsen skillfully evoking jolly sounds from the splendid 1981 Noack tracker instrument of Grace Episcopal Church. Non-congregational psalm settings were interspersed, courtesy of the Calvin College Alumni Choir, conducted by Pearl Shangkuan. A thunder crash and an exceedingly-near lightning strike prefaced Nature's second cloudburst of the day, giving percussive accent to the choir's first notes of Sweelinck's Psalm 65. At that point there were no somnolent singers or listeners in the church!

MHKS founding president Nanette G. Lunde presented a well-played sampling from Arietta con 50 Variazioni per il Clavicembalo by Israel Gottlieb Wernicke and a Sonatina by Johann Daniel Berlin in her Saturday morning program of early keyboard music from Norway. The "Gottlieb Variations" occasionally seemed to attempt emulation of the masterful Goldberg Variations of J. S. Bach, but save for two charming double counterpoint movements (22 and 23) and a March in French Overture Style (number 42) there would be little reason to hear them again.

The program Passion and Repose: an Italian Musical Tableau gave a welcome opportunity to share the fascinating and revelatory repertoire played by the ensemble La Gente d'Orfeo (Daniel Foster, violin; Kiri Tollaksen, cornetto; Debra Lonergan, cello; and Martha Folts, organ and virginal). Splendid works by Scarini, Dario Castello, Biagio Marini, and Giovanni Picchi were elegantly articulated and lovingly presented. Of special poignancy was Folts' dedication of Picchi's Toccata to the recently departed builder of her virginal, Peter S. O'Donnell. A second, if even gentler, highlight of the afternoon was Gregory Crowell's program on his newly acquired Dolmetsch-Chickering clavichord (number 6, built in 1906), which he shared with soprano Kathryn Stieler. Together they created true chamber music as she scaled her attractive voice to the instrument's dynamic, remaining seated as she sang. Johann Krieger's Es ist mir von Natur gegeben was particularly apt, with its rapturous three-stanza expression of appreciation and love for the clavichord.

Todd Decker's brilliant exploration of Domenico Scarlatti's School of Virtuosity: the Essercizi per Gravicembalo proceeded from his viewpoint that these thirty published sonatas are best understood as a methodical progression of technical challenges. His lucid handout supported this thesis, and his competent ease in demonstrating even the most technically challenging of the Essercizi at the harpsichord certainly impressed this listener. A doctoral student in historical musicology at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Mr. Decker is a gifted younger scholar-performer, whom I hope to hear again in the very near future.

David Pickett's humorous and interesting talk on some of the ways a composer's notation may affect our understanding of the score began with a quotation from British comedians Flanders and Swann, proceeded through Telemann's graphic scribing of a Lilliputian Chaconne (in tiny notes) and his contrastingly 24/1 metered Brobdingnagian Minuet, concluding with a short foray into the works of Brahms, and the composer's brief use of the alto clef in the opus 122 organ chorale prelude O Gott, du frommer Gott.

Beside concerts and papers during this varied two-day meeting we heard a panel discussion on practical matters in current early music performance, with comments from Skip Sempé and David Sutherland; many of us enjoyed walking through the forested landscapes and seeing the well-chosen and abundant outdoor sculptures on the relatively-new Grand Valley University campus; and we benefited once again from sharing communal meals, included in the low registration fee. Many of us chose to lodge in a campus dormitory (for a very reasonable amount). The only disadvantage to this arrangement was the unavailability of a nearby campus breakfast spot. To remedy this problem Chairman Crowell delivered bagels and cream cheese to the dorm before Saturday's schedule began--a much appreciated and thoughtful gesture.

In addition to the concert harpsichords by Douglas Maple, builders Ben Bechtel and Ed Kottick displayed examples of their work. Numerically, pride of place went to a bevy of bonny clavichords: instruments by Thomas Wolf, Doug Maple, David Sutherland, Roger Plaxton; and, just arrived from England, Crowell's newest acquisition, a double-fretted clavichord by Peter Bavington were all available for trying out.

At the Society's annual business meeting MHKS President Bruce Glenny announced that the Midwesterners would meet with the Southeastern Historical Keyboard Society in 2005.  The next gathering is set for March 3-5 at Stetson University, in Deland, Florida.

Traveling to Grand Rapids, planned as a simple (if early) direct flight from Dallas to Michigan, became more complicated when storms over the Great Lakes forced the cancellation of that non-stop flight. Twelve hours and an additional airport later, slightly groggy and very hungry, I made it. On the plus side, however, my luggage was already there. You win some, you lose some, but this MHKS annual meeting of 2004 was worth the trip.

Harpsichord News

Larry Palmer

Larry Palmer is a contributing editor of THE DIAPASON.

Default

 

Celebrating the Couperin

 

 

 

 

Jane Clark and Derek Connon: The mirror of human life: Reflections on François Couperin's Pièces de Clavecin. King's Music, 2002.

 

School of Politesse: François Couperin Pièces de Clavecin (Ordre 1, pieces 1-6; Ordres 6, 13, 19, and 27 complete, played by Jane Clark, harpsichordist). Janiculum compact disc (JAN D206). Book and recording available in the US ($16.99 each, plus postage) from Rhinebeck Records <rhinebeckrecords@compu serve.com>.

 

Complete Seventeenth-Century French Unmeasured Preludes, played by Nannette G. Lunde, harpsichordist. Sparrow CD 101 (two compact discs issued in 2002) available from Skyline Publications <www.skylinestudio.com&gt;.

 

Armand-Louis Couperin: Pièces de Clavecin played by Brigitte Haudebourg. Arcobaleno compact disc AAOC-94352 (issued in 1999) <www.kuysleis.com&gt;.

 

 

 

Indispensable! One word characterizes this new book by Jane Clark and Derek Connon.

 

The largest part of the paperbound volume (pages 47-109) consists of a catalogue of movements making up the four books of François Couperin's Pièces de clavecin. From ordre to magnificent ordre, Jane Clark shares the most recent discoveries about the composer's often-elusive titles. In her introductory essay "Aspects of the social and cultural background" Clark writes of Couperin's connections to the Bourbon-Condé family, in particular to the music-loving Mlle de Charlolais (later the Duchesse Du Maine), facilitator, at the châteaux of Châtenay and Sceaux, of aristocratic theatrical entertainments, many of which have direct bearing on Couperin's music.

 

"Aspects of the literary scene" is Derek Connon's compendium concerning the increasingly-conservative French court during Couperin's time, the transvestite Abbé de Choisy, satiric offerings by the imported Italian theatrical troupes and their contrast to the style of the French Theatre, vaudeville, songwriters, the Fair theatres, and the Calotins. Both Clark and Connon note that Couperin had wide-ranging, non-highbrow literary tastes, and a particular interest in uniting Italian and French influences in his music.

 

In her choice of repertoire for the book's separate-but-complementary compact disc, Jane Clark "attempts to illustrate Couperin's theatrical sense" as it developed through the successive volumes of his Pièces de clavecin. In this traversal she succeeds elegantly, abetted by the properly-French timbres of her Feldberg Whale harpsichord after Jean Goujon.

 

 

 

Nannette G. Lunde's two-disc set comprising all the known 17th-century French unmeasured preludes for harpsichord is also a distinguished addition to the harpsichord discography. Beginning with sixteen "white-note" preludes of Louis Couperin, she continues with the multiple pieces in this style by Nicolas Lebègue, Elisabeth-Claude Jacquet de la Guerre, Jean Henry d'Anglebert, Louis-Nicolas Clérambault, Gaspard Le Roux, and unique examples from the pens of Marchand, Rameau, Siret, and Michel (?) Forqueray. Twenty-nine anonymous preludes from widely-dispersed manuscripts complete this comprehensive project.

 

Lunde plays with style, conviction, and, above all, musicality in this often problem-plagued repertoire. Her solutions for organizing the improvisatory works are sensible, her artistry subtle, and the sounds from her 1988 Willard Martin harpsichord (after a Blanchet instrument of 1720), appropriate. Tuning in 1/4-comma meantone temperament and her choice of a low "French opera" pitch (A=392) allow these works to sound both pungent and dark-hued.

 

A suggestion to listeners: approach these discs as you would a large selection of appetizers from a gourmet menu! Too many at one time could lead to aural distress. The preludes were intended to preface dance movements or to test tunings. Use them as introductions to other, more rhythmically-structured works; savor the preludes one or two at a time, thus avoiding an oversdose.

 

 

 

Harpsichordist Brigitte Haudebourg achieved a first prize at the Paris Conservatoire in 1963 (studying with Marcelle Delacour and Robert Veyron-Lacroix). Since then she has pursued a successful career as soloist, continues as artistic director of an international summer festival of baroque art and music in Tarentaise, and has recorded at least fifty compact discs! She gives annual master classes at American universities in Laramie and Houston.

 

Haudebourg's playing of the (nearly) complete harpsichord works of Armand-Louis Couperin gives much pleasure. (The only solo works omitted from this disc are four pieces comprising "Les Nations"—a somewhat tongue-in-cheek glorification of French music in which the composer saved the best representation for his own country, following less-flattering musical evocations of the English, Italians, and Germans.)

 

Gems in this collection include the virtuosic Les Cacqueteuses (fowl humor), l'Arlequine (a piece that stands up well in comparison to the work of the same name by Armand-Louis' predecessor François), and the wrenching l'Affligée (with its particularly poignant harmonies in the pathetic key of B-flat minor).

 

An "edition" by Haudebourg of these pieces for the French publisher Zurfluh consists of the original 1751 publication in facsimile, with slightly more than a page of commentary (in French) containing biographical information plus a few sentences about some of the people referred to in the titles. This same information, complete with English translation, may be found in the notes to the compact disc.

 

The harpsichord music of Armand-Louis Couperin presents a particularly felicitous choice for playing from facsimile, since most of the pieces utilize the familiar treble and bass clefs of present-day usage. Only three works detour into the alto (C) clef for a few measures (Allemande, Arlequine, and Affligée). For many years I have played from a facsimile issued in Basel, Switzerland by Mark Meadow (under the imprint Musica Musica). Like the readily available and clear facsimile edition published by Broude Brothers Limited in their Performers' Facsimile series (PF41; $17.50), Meadow based his reprint on an original in the Library of Congress, uniquely identifiable by the Couperin signature scrawled at the lower right of the first page of La Victoire, the opening piece in the volume.

 

To learn more about Mme Victoire, to whom A-L Couperin dedicated his Pièces de clavecin, consult the indispensable book by Clark and Connon! Thus we come full circle in this celebration of France's major musical dynasty.

 

 

 

Send news items or comments about Harpsichord News to Dr. Larry Palmer, Division of Music, Southern Methodist University, Dallas, TX 75275        ([email protected]).

Nunc Dimittis

Default

Virginia French Mackie died in her sleep at home in Santa Fe, New Mexico on June 20. Born August 15, 1900, in Lancaster, Missouri, she moved in early childhood with her family to Hutchinson, Kansas.

Music was a vital part of her life from the age of three, when she began piano lessons with her mother. She began playing the organ for church before her feet could reach the pedals. By the time she graduated from high school, she had composed the Hutchinson school song, still performed to this day.

At 17 she entered Wellesley College, where she was elected to Phi Beta Kappa during her junior year, and, as a senior, won the Billings Prize for excellence in music. Conducting the orchestra was one of her many musical contributions to the school. Socially conscious, she remembered marching five miles in high heels, as a supporter of the Constitutional amendment giving women the right to vote! Following her graduation from Wellesley in 1921, Virginia entered Columbia University, where she was awarded the MM degree as one of only two women in her class.

She began her career as a junior college teacher in Kansas City, where she met David C. Mackie, a banker whom she married in 1928. The couple moved to New Haven, Connecticut, where David enrolled in the Yale School of Architecture, while Virginia commuted to Northampton to teach music at Smith College.

Summers were spent in England and France. Virginia studied with Tobias Matthay in London, and with Nadia Boulanger at Fontainebleau, where Mrs. Mackie was awarded one of only two diplomas given to women at the École de Musique.

In 1934 the Mackies returned to Kansas City. David began his architectural practice and Virginia joined the faculty of the University of Missouri at Kansas City, where she taught as a distinguished professor for 25 years. During that time she maintained an affiliation with the Yale School of Music, teaching there in 18 summer sessions.

In 1963 the Mackies moved to Tucson, Arizona, and Virginia was invited to join the faculty of the University of Arizona, where she taught for 12 years. Arizona awarded her an honorary degree in recognition of her contributions to the musical life of the community.

After David's death in 1975, Mrs. Mackie moved to New Mexico, where she was named a Living Treasure of Santa Fe in 1994. She was invited back to Kansas City to present a series of lectures and performances of works by Franz Joseph Haydn, one of her favorite composers, and to receive an honorary doctor of music degree from the University of Missouri, Kansas City in 1989, joining Count Basie as only the second musician to be so recognized by the school. Virginia Mackie continued to teach harpsichord and piano in Santa Fe well past her 100th birthday in 2000.

--Larry Palmer (Based on an obituary [22 June 2005] in The Santa Fe New Mexican)

Theatre organist Billy Nalle of Fort Myers, Florida, died on June 7. Born in Fort Myers April 24, 1921, he was a piano prodigy at age three, when he started picking out melodies, and began playing in public at age four. He graduated from Fort Myers High School in 1939, receiving the American Legion Honor Award. From 1933–39 he was pianist of the Al Linquist Jazz Orchestra of Fort Myers and perfomed solo organ work on station WINK. During these years Billy studied under Eddie Ford, organist at the Tampa Theatre, and became Eddie's assistant. Later, he performed a stint at the Florida Theatre, Jacksonville.

He studied piano and organ at the Juilliard School of Music; principal teachers were the organ and piano virtuoso Gaston Dethier and Teddy Wilson, pianist of the Benny Goodman Orchestra. During this same time, Billy had organ engagements at the Manhattan Beacon Theatre, Brooklyn Paramount, and the Waldorf-Astoria ballroom.

Nalle served in the U.S. Navy 1943–46 and during his last year of service was assigned to the U.S.N. Entertainment Unit, where he, Lawrence Welk, vocalist Bobby Beers, and noted choreographer Bob Fosse toured the Pacific Ocean military bases. During 1947 and 1948, he did postgraduate studies at The Juilliard School, and then began a 26-year career in New York City providing music for more than 200 television shows on CBS, NBC and ABC. Billy appeared on over 5,000 telecasts, an unparalleled record for an organ soloist. As well as solo appearances on major television programs such as "Kraft Theatre" and the "Downbeat Show," Billy had the distinction of appearing as an organ soloist on the "Ed Sullivan Show" the same evening that Elvis Presley appeared for the first time. Throughout his theatre organ performing career, he was featured in concerts at countless public venues throughout the country and for several national conventions of the American Theatre Organ Society.

In 1957, Billy's recording career began when RCA tapped him to record "Swingin' Pipe Organ," an LP commemorating the work of trombonist Tommy Dorsey. Nalle recorded this at the Times Square Paramount Wurlitzer with George Shearing's drummer, Ray Mosca, and it is still considered a landmark recording in theatre organ circles. Numerous commercial recordings followed on Wurlitzer organs installed at the Century II Center (Wichita), Brooklyn Paramount Theatre (aka: Long Island University), Senate Theatre (Detroit) and Auditorium Theatre (Rochester, New York). Currently, Wichita Theatre Organ is in the process of producing a series of recordings drawn from his many live concerts performed on the Wichita Wurlitzer, scheduled for release later this year.

Billy's concert career did not actually start until age 45, when he performed for a national convention of the American Guild of Organists at the Fox Theatre in Atlanta, Georgia in 1966. It was the first formal theatre organ concert in the group's history, and received a rave review in Audio magazine, the Atlanta Constitution and the New York Times. The latter newspaper featured his career in three major articles, and sometime later Billy's life was the object of a feature in the Wichitan magazine. A writer himself, Billy supplied reviews and articles to national publications, including a four-year news column in the AGO-RCCO publication, Music.

As a composer member of the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP), Billy had numerous compositions to his credit. However, he may be best remembered by church musicians and theatre organists alike with his published arrangement of Jerome Kern's "All The Things You Are" in the form of a Bach trio sonata, entitled Alles was du bist. Billy once remarked that he did better financially on the rights gleaned from this arrangement than any other single thing he ever did.

In 1975, Billy accepted the position of Artist-in-Residence at the Century II Center in Wichita, Kansas, where the 4-manual, 36-rank Wurlitzer from the Times Square Paramount Theatre had been relocated. For eleven years, he played concerts in the Wichita Pops series, made numerous recordings and continued to concertize nationally. In 1993, the American Theatre Organ Society voted him into their Hall of Fame. In 1995, Nalle ended a full-time career and returned to Fort Myers, Florida, where he lived until his death.

He always prided himself on his ever-growing list of "firsts," including the first theatre organ concert to be performed at The Church of St. John The Divine, New York City. In a relatively brief period of twenty years, Billy performed twenty-five national and international music firsts on a theatre organ.

Billy was a man of strong convictions and deep religious faith. In the years just prior to leaving Wichita, he was active in the formation of St. Joseph of Glastonbury Anglican Catholic Church, the city's first Anglican place of worship. In his tiny efficiency apartment, he managed to find space for an altar and several religious icons. In fact, his living space was much like his playing: filled to the hilt with interesting "stuff" without feeling the least bit cluttered.

He was always full of stories about the great concerts he attended while living in New York and the personalities he encountered. One of his favorites was about his friendship with organist Virgil Fox, who lived only a short distance away from his apartment. Fox had been contracted by Wichita Theatre Organ to perform a concert at Centuy II (eventually released by RCA on LP as "The Entertainer") and sought Billy's advice on how to handle the Wurlitzer, just prior to Billy's move there. Fox wanted to stick to the classics, but Billy suggested that, as an encore piece, he should choose a simple, well-known melody and improvise on it. Fox out-and-out refused. "Why not?" said the ever-inquisitive Billy. Fox leaned over the dinner table, looked Billy straight in the eye and whispered, "I'll tell you why: too hard . . . that's why!"

To the end, Billy was a complete original, always encouraging young musicians to be themselves, and not to get caught up in what was stylistically popular at the moment. He was inexhaustible as a resource. Right to the end of his career, he was a developing musician, never casting anything completely in stone. Kind, thoughtful, sensitive, highly intelligent and a fine conversationalist--all will remember Billy as the consummate southern gentleman.

Paraphrasing his first Wichita LP seems to say it all: There (was) only one Billy Nalle.

--Scott Smith

Lansing, Michigan

The Rev. William F. Parker, of Atlantic City and Philadelphia, died on April 16. Born in Philadelphia and raised in Margate, he graduated from Temple University and the Temple University Theological Seminary, and earned his Master of Divinity degree from Princeton University. An ordained Presbyterian minister, he was pastor at Lower Bank Methodist Circuit, New Jersey, Mizpah Presbyterian Church, Philadelphia, and Leeds Point Presbyterian Church. For 24 years he served as pastor at Olivet Presbyterian Church in Atlantic City. He was also an experienced organist, serving for a number of churches and synagogues in the Philadelphia area, and was organist for St. James Episcopal Church in Atlantic City and Old St. George's Methodist Church in Philadelphia.

William Parker is survived by his sister, Helen Holmes Parker. A memorial organ recital will take place on October 15 at First Presbyterian Church, Philadelphia, with Joseph Jackson as organist.

Harpsichord News

Harpsichord Workshop IX: SMU-in-Taos

by Nancy Ypma

Dr. Nancy S. Ypma teaches organ at McKendree College, Lebanon, Illinois.

Default

SMU's ninth summer harpsichord workshop took place at its Fort Burgwin campus near Taos, New Mexico, August 11-17, 1996. Fourteen registrants from California, Illinois, Missouri, New Mexico, New York, Pennsylvania, Texas, Virginia, and Washington participated in the week-long course led by Jane Clark and Stephen Dodgson (London) and Larry Palmer (Dallas).

Each morning Jane Clark's master class on the keyboard
music of François Couperin focused on the background to the pieces in
his Pièces de Clavecin. Clark's insights into society, royalty, and the history of the time helped to explain  the meanings for many of the titles and gave direction toward an effective interpretation. Participants performed many of the pieces for Ms. Clark, who guided them with comments on performance practices and technique.

Early afternoon sessions were led by Larry Palmer. During
the first four days Dr. Palmer concentrated on the eight preludes of Couperin's
L'art de toucher le clavecin. He emphasized articulation, ornamentation,
and the pedagogical value of these pieces. On the final day, he turned to some
of Bach's Little Preludes. Participants took turns playing for the class,
and Dr. Palmer worked with each student in such a way that all participants,
regardless of background, discovered something new about the music or the
composer.

Later afternoon sessions were in the hands of Stephen
Dodgson, who received his training at the Royal College of Music, London, where
he taught composition and theory for many years. He discussed his long-term
fascination with the harpsichord and his extensive repertoire of solo and
ensemble music for the instrument. Each student had been sent a set of
Dodgson's pieces prior to the class, so many participants opted to play
works for the composer. Dodgson gave special insight into his pieces through
liberal sharing of anecdotes, by the example of his own playing, and by both
coaxing and coaching players through these attractive pieces.

Single- and double-manual instruments by Dowd, Kingston,
Wolf, and Martin had been transported from Dallas for the workshop, so all
participants were able to practice on fine harpsichords in a variety of styles.
Because of the size of the class, everyone had an opportunity to play each
instrument.

In the evenings there was a variety of events throughout the
week. On Monday Larry Palmer gave a recital of works by Louis, François,
and Armand-Louis Couperin; Frescobaldi; J.S. Bach; Martinu; and Dodgson. On
Tuesday Richard Kingston, resident harpsichord maker for the week, lectured on
harpsichord styles as the class moved from Italian to French to German-style
instruments. On Wednesday many people chose to attend the Santa Fe Opera
production of Stravinsky's The Rake's Progress (which, fittingly
enough, includes harpsichord in its scoring). On Thursday evening Jane Clark
played works by François Couperin, Domenico Scarlatti, Frescobaldi, and
her husband Stephen Dodgson, whose Carillon for Two Harpsichords concluded her
program. Larry Palmer was her partner for this performance.

The week concluded on Saturday with a lunch and impromptu
harpsichord recital (by any participant who wished to play) at the home of
Charles and Susan Mize (outside the village of Tesuque, near Santa Fe).
Hummingbirds swooped to their feeders on the patio of this charming adobe
retreat while workshop participants enjoyed a gourmet lunch and music in a
relaxed atmosphere.

Harpsichord Workshop IX was an inspiring and invigorating
week of study for all the prticipants, amateur performers and professional
musicians alike.

Harpsichord News

by Larry Palmer
Default

New (Old) Music for Harpsichord

First Facsimiles

New from the French publisher J. M. Fuzeau is a two-volume set of facsimiles enclosed in a folder-like cover [Premiers Fac-Similés: Clavecin]. De-signed to introduce harpsichordists to the art of playing from original notation, this selection (by Laure Morabito and Aline Zylberajch) is the first of a projected series for use by players of various historic instruments.

Clean printing and no awkward page turns make this a very attractive publication. Notational problems are introduced in an orderly way, but the volumes will be utilized best with the help of a teacher. There are no written guides or explanations of earlier notational conventions or of ornamentation.  Unlike most of Fuzeau's previous publications, there is no help for the French-challenged here: a one-page introduction appears only in French.

A look through some of the fifteen short pieces in Volume One will indicate some benefits to be gained from playing through this collection. Clear and easily read, the first four pieces (by Dandrieu, F. Couperin, and Duphly) present no notational problems. Potential questions appear first in Duphly's La Felix: an accidental—a missing B-natural in the penultimate measure of the last score, and an extra ledger line engraved in measure five of the second score indicate that one must begin at once to trust ears and not rely only on the score, even if it is a reprinting of  the original engraving.

In the wonderfully bizarre Preludio by Friedrich Wilhelm Marpurg (from Fughe e Capricci, Berlin, c. 1777) should one really play the engraved C-sharp in the soprano against a C-natural in the bass [second score, second measure] or did the engraver simply jump the gun to set up the measure one score beneath, where an F-sharp works perfectly well above the D in the bass?  A student might well question, as well, the meaning of the printed directions "Con Discrezione" and "Arpeg: ad libit."  Finally to confound one even further, this single-page example concludes not on the tonic, but in the dominant, requiring for its resolution a [non-included] Caprice which followed the Preludio in the 18th-century source.

The first example of an "abnormal" clef comes in the next piece, Dandrieu's L'Empressée, where the bass part contains 12 measures written in the alto clef.  There is much more use of this clef in the following piece by Dandrieu (La Sensible), and the soprano clef is used in the next (L'Afectueuse), which introduces, additionally, the use of a flat rather than the modern natural for canceling a sharp.

In Balbastre's La d'Hericourt one encounters the 18th-century conventions for notation of first and second endings, as well as the composer's preferred notes for this piece (compared with several wrong ones in the modern reprinting of Alan Curtis's edition for Le Pupitre). Also preferable in the facsimile is the [original] layout, which requires no awkward page turning.

More clef practice is required in two F. Couperin pieces and in the Courante of the Suite in D minor by L-C Daquin.  Both the Allemande and Courante from this Suite end with a Petite Reprise, requiring the player to figure out the proper "road map" for negotiating the works.

In the second volume one encounters fourteen more pieces, including several slightly unmeasured preludes (by Mar-chand and Rameau), a Menuet by Elizabeth Jacquet de La Guerre, and later works by Gottlieb Muffat, J. C. Bach, Graupner, Eckard, and Cherubini.

I intend to use these volumes for expanding the horizons of my harpsichord students, and I recommend them highly.  Fuzeau's order number for the set is Ref. 7075; they are reasonably priced at 12,14 Euros, and may be ordered via the Web at

www.fuzeau.com or from Editions J. M. Fuzeau, B.P.6, 79440 Courlay, France.

A Toccata and Two Transcriptions

From the opposite side of the world come three publications issued by Saraband Music, 10 Hawkins Street, Artarmon NSW 2064 Australia (Web: www.saraband.com.au;

e-mail <[email protected]>). Editor Rosalind Halton has ascertained that a Toccata for Harpsichord from the musical manuscripts of the Santini Collection in the Diözesan Bibliothek, Münster, is the work of Alessandro Scarlatti. This is a fine work, surely the most interesting keyboard work thus far from a  composer much better known for his vocal works and operas. The bulk of the piece (96 measures) consists of an opening chordal section [perhaps to be played "adagio and arpeggiando"?], an allegro, adagio, allegro, and a lengthy, spirited imitative section which would make a fine conclusion.  Strangely, there follows a somewhat inconsequential page in 3/8 meter (a Minuet, perhaps?) in which, for the only time in this edition, I would question the accidentals as they are printed: in bar 101, surely the F in the descending bass scale should be a natural (not indicated); and, in bar 107, the ascending B at the end of the measure should be a natural. The order number for this appealing work is SM24 (priced at A$10).

The two transcriptions, both by Pastor de Lasala, are Antonio Vivaldi's Concerto in G minor, RV531, his only known Concerto for Two Cellos and Orchestra, and a keyboard reworking of Gluck's Dance of the Furies (originally composed for the ballet Don Juan, later inserted into a Paris production of Orfeo ed Euridice in 1774).  (Vivaldi: SM35, A$15; Gluck: SM 37, A$12).

The Vivaldi is a pleasant three-movement work that suffers, to my ears, from a lack of variety in its tessitura.  I experimented with transposing some of the passages down an octave to take advantage of a more resonant register of the harpsichord, and also to suggest more closely the timbre of the two original solo instruments.  So, my suggestion is that the performer should join in the fun of transcribing this one.  Quite successful, however, is the Gluck "toccata," a welcome addition to the repertoire from a composer who has left no known keyboard music. The nobility and simplicity of Gluck's Classic idiom is most appealing in this keyboard adaptation, and the piece, familiar to many, will add interest and a welcome variety to a harpsichord solo program. The idea of such a transcription has a valid and distinguished historical precedent, too: Gluck's Ouverture to Iphigénie en Aulide may be found in keyboard guise in Martha Jefferson Randolph's Manuscript Music Book (now housed in the Jefferson family music collection at the University of Virginia, Charlottesville).

Sarabande publications are available in the U. S. through the Boulder Early Music Shop, 1822 Powell Street, Erie,  CO 80516 or at P. O. Box 428, Lafay-ette, CO 80026 (e-mail: [email protected]; website: http://www.bems.com).

Current Issue