New Organs

Gober Organs, Inc.,

Elora, Ontario, Canada

First Church in Oberlin,

United Church of Christ,

Oberlin, Ohio

The opportunity to build a new tracker organ for First Church in Oberlin, Ohio afforded us the opportunity to interpret traditional organbuilding principles in the light of the aesthetic and acoustical demands of this historic congregation’s 19th-century building, as well as the community’s culture.

The town of Oberlin was founded in 1834 by settlers coming to what was then the Western Reserve of the original States. From the outset, the community was marked by a religious fervor, even a certain similarity to utopian communities common in the United States at the time. For decades, the pastor of this congregation, as well as the president of Oberlin College, was Charles Grandison Finney, famed throughout the United States as an evangelistic leader. The town was a hotbed of socially progressive activity. Two focuses in that realm were the abolitionist movement opposing slavery, and the temperance movement, which sought to improve the quality of life among working families by expounding the moral and practical benefits of abstinence from alcohol use. The memory of abolitionism remains visible today in the form of local monuments and historic sites relating to Oberlin’s role as a station on the Underground Railroad. (The long-ended activities of the Women’s Christian Temperance Union had effects on liquor bylaws in the town until very recently.) The tradition of political positions espoused by groups and individuals in the community—both in the college, the dominant cultural force in town these days, and in the town at large including its churches—is a clear outgrowth of a heritage dating back to its beginnings.

The other obvious context our new organ finds itself in is that of the opulent array of organs found in the town’s churches and in the buildings of Oberlin College and its Conservatory of Music. One of these organs, a Barckhoff organ in Peace Community Church, was built in the 19th century. All the others relate more or less directly to another progressive wave, one that swept Oberlin in the 20th century: the organ reform movement. They range from the conservatory’s two one-manual Flentrop organs from the mid and late 1950s—one of which had been in the Busch-Reisinger Museum in Cambridge, Massachusetts, prior to the arrival of the 3-manual organ there—to the Cavaillé-Coll-style Fisk organ in Finney Chapel, completed in 2001. The whole assemblage numbers about 30 organs, including practice instruments and continuo organs, built by Brombaugh, Bedient, Noack, and Holtkamp, among others. My employees and I have taken care of most of these instruments for almost fifteen years, and can attest to the compelling nature of the collection both in terms of its overall quality and as an admonishment against hubris in planning and building fine pipe organs.

The sanctuary of First Church, known as the Meeting House, in the tradition of New England Congregational churches, is a spare, nearly square room with a flat ceiling, white walls, and lots of light pouring in through tall windows with small panes of streaky glass. The seating capacity is over 1000 in pews both on the ground level and a balcony, which surrounds the room and forms the choir loft at the front.

First Church has had various organs, the first one having been built by Hook & Hastings in the 19th century. Successive modifications of the Meeting House since then were accompanied by new organs, most recently an electropneumatic one built by Homer Blanchard in 1962. It was assembled from a variety of components old and new and housed in a handsome neo-classical case, a holdover from an earlier Estey organ. The Blanchard organ included some windchests, swell boxes, and ranks of pipes from E. M. Skinner Opus 230, originally built in 1914 for the no longer extant Second Church in Oberlin.

In replacing the still serviceable 1962 organ, the church’s goal was to have a mechanical-action instrument that would convincingly fill the Meeting House in spite of its rather dry acoustics, while drawing more on historical antecedents than its predecessor had. By the time I was approached for a proposal for an organ, it had become clear to the First Church organ committee that although the previous organ had had three manuals, it would be more rational to concentrate a new organ’s resources on two manuals.

This new organ was to become an instrument whose focus, apart from the accompaniment of the congregation singing traditional Protestant hymns—including many from the 19th century that remain a staple—would be the performance of organ literature, not least that of the post-1800 era. Its specification bears some resemblance to a Hook organ of similar size, but there are differences—the lack of an Aeoline, or echo string, and the inclusion of a large treble Cornet in the Great, for example, relating to the performance of literature that we view as canonical, and our relative lack of interest today in playing the transcriptions of orchestral and popular music that were de rigueur.

The congregation’s desire to keep the existing organ case seemed obvious, both from a practical standpoint and from the wish to preserve the accrued history of the building. The case is large and located in the ideal position in the church, though not shaped at all like a typical mechanical organ, being 30' wide and 10' deep but only 18' high. Nonetheless, it was possible to fit our organ’s design into the logical matrix that defines a well-conceived tracker organ: the major third pipe layouts result in the compactness necessary for simple, short and optimally light action, while providing plenty of space for the pipes to speak and easy tuning accessibility. And the direct relationship between windchest layout and façade permits straightforward and efficient winding of speaking façade pipes.

The two manual divisions are located across the center half or so of the case, the Great in front and the Swell behind. The bass and tenor pipes of the Great Diapason 8' are in reverse chest order in the façade’s center opening. The Pedal windchests are at either end of the case, and their façade pipes are the tenor range of the Pedal Diapason 16', interspersed with those of the prepared-for Violoncello 16', following the major third layout of the chests. Ours is not a large organ in number of stops, but each stop is complete—each of the 8' foundation stops is present from low C, and, given the generous pipe scaling throughout, the organ fills the case completely.

The appearance of the organ exterior is little changed. The mouths of each group of façade pipes, of 70% tin, now form a garland-like curve mirroring the arched openings in which they stand. The new keydesk en fenêtre, in contrast to the white painted case, is of solid mortise-and-tenon, frame-and-panel black walnut with a natural oil finish. The stop names on the drawknobs were written in a style evocative of 19th-century American organs by Toronto calligrapher Diane Iannuziello and scanned and laser-engraved onto the faces.

In seeking antecedents for our organ, I considered the history of the congregation and its building in the perspective of their origins as a settlement of a New England Congregationalist group. The First Church sanctuary is a large, nearly square flat-ceilinged room surrounded on all sides by a balcony, which in the front of the room forms the choir loft. Although it is a solid 19th-century building, it is acoustically unsupportive, with its large windows, partly carpeted wooden floor, and cushions on many of the pews. The surface which, given the location of the organ high up in the room, should be most supportive of the organ’s tone, is the ceiling. But it consists only of a single thickness of drywall, the result of a renovation that saw the removal of the original plaster ceiling.

This is not unlike the situation for which many of Hook & Hastings’ organs were conceived. I visited several of their instruments seeking a better understanding of how they filled such rooms with music. Here I found foundation stops that are a world away from wispy neo-Baroque principals. The diameter of a typical Hook Great Principal is larger than the Pedal Principal of many a 20th-century tracker. Such pipes are capable of giving forth a strong fundamental tone without being “pushed” using ears or beards, and it was just such a broad, unforced foundation that First Church’s new organ would require.
By the same token, the most striking stop from Skinner Opus 230 that was still playing at First Church was the Pedal Open Wood Diapason 16¢, a stronger cousin of corresponding stops in Hook organs. The effect that extremely powerful stop had in First Church’s dry acoustic could be likened to that of a healthy Subbass in a resonant room. It was evident that those Skinner pipes needed to become part of our new organ, and that the scaling of the organ as a whole would have to be as generous as that of the Hook pipes I had examined. The higher-pitched elements in the principal choruses did not require the same kind of departure from our norm, but I also lavished attention on the scaling of the reed stops in order to obtain an effortless strength from the fundamental with no hint of harshness.

Besides the Wood Diapason, there were other stops from Skinner Opus 230 that I felt had a place in such a scheme—in spite of the seeming improbability of Skinner pipes in a tracker organ. These included, in addition to the Pedal Wood Diapason and Bourdon, the Swell Bourdons 16' and 8', the Viola da Gamba and Vox Coelestis, and two 4¢ traverse flutes, one of which became a 2' in our organ. What I was banking on with these manual stops was the potential for infusing them with new life by opening the toeholes to more than compensate for the somewhat lower wind pressure we used. For the strings, that was the sole voicing adjustment needed; in the case of the flutes, I further optimized the tone by adjusting the other major factors, the windway size and languid position, just as I do with new pipes. For all the stops, the effect was great—in spite of the heavily nicked languids, those stops speak with greater intensity than they did in the predecessor organ and are very much at home in this organ’s overall sound. The Skinner organ’s Clarinet will also take its place as a second reed in the Great when funds become available.

Another element from the 1914 Skinner instrument that we reused to great advantage is the swell frames from both the Swell and Choir boxes, with their priceless sugar pine shutters. They are on three sides of the large swell box. To maximize the damping effect of the closed Swell box, all of its other surfaces are double-walled with dead air spaces between. The resulting dynamic range exceeded our wildest expectations.

The organ is tuned in a new, slightly unequal temperament devised by Oberlin organ performance student Titus van den Heuvel. In contrast to other unequal temperaments, it favors keys in the flat and sharp directions from C major equally, a valuable feature in a church where many hymns are sung in the “many flat” realm.

The organ’s presence in the Meeting House was enhanced through acoustical improvements specified by acoustician Dana Kirkegaard. These amount to an unseen “bandshell” behind and above the organ. At the rear, hardboard was installed inside the church’s exterior brick and the void between filled with vermiculite, harnessing the solidity of the masonry and providing heat insulation. The very essential and particularly laborious ceiling reinforcement was undertaken with great vigor by a stalwart team of volunteers from the congregation. In the front third of the church, over the organ and choir, lightweight but highly rigid panels consisting of corrugated cardboard sandwiched between thicknesses of plywood were added above the ceiling. The installation of this material entailed trimming individual pieces to fit in the irregular spaces between the 19th-century ceiling joists, then bonding them securely to the top side of the drywall using gallons of adhesive—without this step, the presence of the panels would have had no effect.

The organ was dedicated as the Cauffiel Organ, honoring musician Jane Cauffiel Thomson, a long-time Oberlin resident and First Church member, whose visionary idea and generous gift towards the building of a new organ got this project started. An inaugural recital played jointly by Oberlin Conservatory professors David Boe and James David Christie took place in September 2004. Since then numerous other concerts have taken place, including a weekly noon series. It was organized by First Church organist Bálint Karosi, a conservatory graduate student who has been a Westfield Center Scholar and competed for the 2006 Grand Prix de Chartres. Other recitalists have included Jean Galard, organiste titulaire of Beauvais Cathedral and St. Medard in Paris, and László Fassang of Budapest and St. Sebastián, Spain. In February 2007, First Church was the scene of a Langlais Festival of the Oberlin Conservatory, which featured a recital and masterclass given by Marie-Louise Langlais. And in addition to its primary use in the weekly services of First Church, the organ is used by both Oberlin Conservatory professors as a teaching instrument two days a week under an arrangement between the conservatory and First Church.

A CD recorded on the organ by Bálint Karosi is forthcoming. It includes performances of works by Bach, Widor, Liszt, and Mr. Karosi himself, and will be available from Gober Organs, Inc., and First Church.
This is the first time in my work I have undertaken a synthesis like this, and it has been a challenge whose pleasures have at least equaled those of designing a new instrument from scratch. I am a firm believer in the principle that constraints foster good art. Some of the constraints here were given, others, like the effort to incorporate historical tonal material, were inspired by the cultural context of the instrument.

Among the people I owe thanks to are Prof. David Boe, who advised the First Church organ committee on this project, and Dr. Harold Slocum, its chair. First Church member David Clark spearheaded the implementation of the physical preparations for the organ’s installation and took care of the generous housing arrangements. Richard Houghten planned and installed the SSL electronic stop and combination action. And last but not least, Gober Organs employees Matthias Schmidt, Wendy McConnell, Burkhard Moeller, Mike Collins, Ian Hathaway, and Hendrik Oudshoorn.

—Halbert Gober



Photo credit: Halbert Gober

Gober Organs, Inc.

50 First Line Road

Elora, Ontario N0B 1S0

Canada

www.goberorgans.com

John-Paul Buzard Pipe Organ Builders, Champaign, Illinois, Opus 34

Mt. Pleasant Lutheran Church (ELCA), Racine, Wisconsin

From the designer and builder

Did you know that the Jetsons are parishioners of Mt. Pleasant Lutheran Church, Racine, Wisconsin? You know them: George, Jane (his wife), daughter Judy, and his boy, Elroy. Outside the world of futuristic fiction, they must have had an influence in the design of this church building, which is locally known as “The Space Ship Church.” Built in 1975, it is a dish with an inverted saucer as its roof; large plate glass windows surround its perimeter, filling in the space at which the two join.

This building’s unique shape determines how it is accessed and used—functionally and liturgically. Ahead of its time in terms of accessibility, upon entering at ground level, one enters the lower level fellowship areas and upper level worship area by a series of switch-back ramps that wind around the building’s diameter. Liturgically, this is a church in “three-quarter round,” which presents its own challenges for communion and processional traffic flow.

The building’s shape also determines its acoustical environment, and therefore the limits of a pipe organ’s physical and tonal design. Consultant Scott Riedel guided the church in improving the acoustics and creating a better area for music-making, by altering the shape of the walls facing the congregation, filling in gaps between ceiling beams, and replacing the carpeting in the choir’s seating area with hardwood flooring. And, in fact, sound is now heard more clearly and evenly through the room, especially in the outer ring of seating at the edge of the room’s diameter. But, the remaining carpet and pew coverings do their work too well, absorbing bass frequencies.

We were able to observe this phenomenon clearly before the church’s former organ was removed. The 16¢ pedal sounds were weak in the church, but in the lower level fellowship hall, the tone boomed to overtake normal conversation.

The organ chamber, while perfectly sited across the front of the worship area, is horizontal in nature, with a maximum ceiling height of 14'. Congregational seating comes to within four feet of the organ’s left side; the choral singers are about eight feet from the right side. The wide layout, and very present location of the organ, demanded that the design be practical, and required a very gentle touch in its scaling and voicing. Since the pipes could not be elevated above the congregation’s heads, the sound is produced directly at the level of people’s ears, requiring very refined voicing. The enclosed accompanimental divisions of the organ needed to be located to the right, nearer the choir, which meant that the Great needed to be on the left. People on the left side of the organ would be only four feet away from the Great Mixture. Oh, yes, there were also four steel roof support columns in the organ chamber, which could not be moved, and had to be worked around.

Those of you who have followed our work, or played our instruments, know that our organs have a smooth, warm, pervading, and significantly grand tone. They can be bright when they need to be, but the various stops are not inherently so. (The last thing we want to do is voice the high pitches in the mixtures to be bright!) Our organs are not crowned by high-pitched mixture-work (as in neo-classic organs), but by the heroic blend that results from mixtures and reeds singing together, reinforcing unison pitch. In the case of this church, we needed to fill the entire building (basement included) with bass frequencies, and gradually decrease the intensity of tone as the pitches rose, in order to have the organ sound smooth, balanced in the tonal spectrum, and consonant with our artistic style. To have achieved the balance it has—whether one is sitting next to the Great Mixture, or in the outside ring—is a testament to the organ’s solid construction, painstaking attention to scaling, and countless hours of listening and adjusting the sounds in the church. Our head voicer, Brian Davis, was promoted to the position of tonal director as a result of this organ’s success in the face of such overwhelming challenges.

The visual design’s “prime directives” were to bring order to random asymmetry, lead the eye toward the center of the worship area, emphasize what little verticality the space actually has, and give a dignified prominence to a steel sculpture in front of the organ—the base of the church’s three-bladed steeple, which pierces the roof and ascends to a needle point in the sky.

The three arms of the steeple are of unequal width, connected by horizontal welded rods, and form a sculpture in the nature of a cross. Original descriptions of the sculpture allude to the Trinitarian symbolism of its three blades. The organ chamber is located immediately behind the sculpture, the center portion curved in the outline of the stone font, the sides on a slightly reverse curve as the chamber returns to the side walls. Aside from the planned asymmetry of the steel sculpture, the exact dimensions and precise placement of the organ chamber behind the sculpture could not be ascertained until the old organ was removed and the chamber developed by moving offices and closets previously flanking the former instrument. The chamber space itself was asymmetrical as registered to the centrally located sculpture.

We decided to design the organ’s façade in three sections, not only to emphasize the Trinitarian symbolism, but to give us some practical constructional flexibility in reconciling the many dimensional variables. Even though everything was accurately constructed in the shop to careful measurements taken once the organ chamber was constructed, we still needed to do more woodworking on-site than we would have liked, or than other situations have ever required.

The center section, being behind the flat-black steel sculpture, needed some visual grounding, but not heaviness. The former organ was basically dark, with lots of black grille-cloth, which made the steel sculpture disappear. We therefore displayed the centrally located large wood pipes in a light, natural finish in the center section, with the horizontal bright polished copper reed resonators wrapping themselves around the sculpture from above and behind. This central display is symmetrical, and acts as a perfect backdrop to gently soften the tension created by the wide-versus-narrow blades of the sculpture in front. The low octave of the 8¢ Pedal Principal flanks this display of the wood pipes, the pipes being mounted on toeboards that follow the curve of the font, to act as a transition to the façade’s side elements.

In order to provide motion, rhythm, and verticality to this horizontal instrument, the left and right sides feature the largest of the polished tin Principal pipes, mounted on casework with a toeboard “sill” lower than that of the center section. The façade pipes’ feet are significantly lower than the windchests in the organ, so we had to hide the chests and reservoirs behind them with black felt to eliminate potential visual confusion. The pipes on the outside edges are supported by arched toeboards, rising above the façade’s sill (or impost if this were an organ case), which we enameled blue to relate to other colors in the room. The largest Pedal Principal pipes we could fit in the façade are from 16¢ FFF, which sit on the floor, to break the horizontal line of the sill and challenge the height of the central steel sculpture. As the compass of this stop ascends, the smaller pipes are racked up on the sill, but the mouth line forms one continuous rising arch, leading the eye inward. Subtle touches of pipe spacing from the edges of the upright casework members were added to subtly influence one’s viewing of the “symmetrically asymmetrical organ.”

The tonal design of this instrument is fairly typical of what we do, with the exception of the four-stop Solo Organ, which is at home on the bottom manual keyboard. The Great, Swell, and Pedal are full and well developed, consonant with our style. The Solo offers some evocative coloristic sounds and the flexibility of a third keyboard in a situation in which there was neither room nor money for a full Choir Organ. Usually our organs’ solo reeds are Tubas. But, in this close acoustic, we were extremely concerned that the high volume, located so close to the listeners, would drive them all out onto Green Bay Road and us out of town on a rail! We therefore opted to make these Trombas, on lower pressure with slightly more open shallots for a relatively dark tone, but at a solo volume in balance with the rest of the organ. The Great 8' Trumpet is truly a luxury. This Trumpet is a beautifully blending chorus reed and also very useful for solo work. The Swell reed battery, though, is what’s worth writing home about! Here’s the power in the organ, beautifully tailored for its uses in a wide variety of contexts, but it is never too loud in the room. The Swell 16' Bassoon, which plays in the Pedal as well, perfectly balances not only the Swell battery, but also the Great full chorus for those many times when it is used as a “pointed” pedal reed and the darker, heavier Trombone would be too much.

It has been a pleasure to work with the people of Mt. Pleasant Lutheran Church, and consultant Scott Riedel, on this new instrument. Pastor Stephen Samuelson, music director Joshua Brown, and the organ committee fell in love with our instruments after hearing the organ we built at St. David’s Episcopal Church, Glenview, Illinois. Their vision for how the new organ would transform their unique worship space was inspiring. It was our privilege to be given the challenges and create something truly beautiful.

—John-Paul Buzard



From the organist and director of music

Like any good Lutheran, I must start with a confession. Five years ago, when I pulled up to Mt. Pleasant Lutheran Church for my first interview, I thought “Who designed this thing, Frank Lloyd Wrong? It embodies disappointing American church architecture with its wide squat room, plenty of carpet and more wasted space than the inside of an SUV!”

Fortunately, like any good Lutheran, I put my trust in God’s abiding grace, and returned to Mt. Pleasant as their organist and director of music to discover the beauty of this building. A ribbon of windows keeps the outside world in plain sight, and the roof line surrounds the building with a crown of thorns. The triune tower rises up from the baptismal font, punctuating this architectural statement, which has served as the church’s very best evangelism tool since its completion 30 years ago!

The church’s former small organ had been assembled in an ad hoc manner through the years, and suffered from the oppressive acoustical environment and poor chamber layout. With the able guidance of Scott Riedel and Associates, the church crafted a plan to remodel the sanctuary, double its reverberation time, and replace the aging organ. The organ committee considered many fine builders. John-Paul Buzard’s warmth of tone, quality of workmanship, and, to quote the Senior Pastor Stephen Samuelson, “bang for the buck,” all contributed to the church’s final selection of his firm.

This unique American church required an equally unique American organbuilder. John-Paul Buzard and his team tackled the church’s twin challenges of odd architecture and unforgiving acoustics with great aplomb. In the process they demonstrated that the best organbuilders, particularly for American churches, need a flexible approach to fit a wide range of applications. From high gothic architecture with grand acoustics to restrained “prairie style” architecture with limited acoustics, John-Paul Buzard has adapted and delivered stunning results while maintaining his tonal style and uncompromising quality.

Opus 34, the result of three years’ careful planning and execution, has both matched and enhanced the sanctuary’s architectural style. More importantly, it has brought an entirely new dynamic to the worship life of the congregation. With a tonal scheme based on a wide array of 8¢ pitches, the organ fully supports the congregation’s singing and easily fills the room with sound. The two complete principal choruses allow the organ to lead congregations of varying sizes, from 10 to 600. The wide selection of reed and flute stops offers ample color and variety for responding to hymn texts and playing repertoire.
The organ was first played for worship on Reformation Sunday 2006, and Mary Preston will play the inaugural recital this month. I am grateful to all of the Buzard staff who worked at a strenuous pace to deliver and install our organ, and to Scott Riedel for his insight and guidance throughout the project. Finally, a special thanks to the staff, worship and music and organ committees, and members of Mt. Pleasant Lutheran Church who had the long-term vision required to undertake this project.

—Joshua Brown

Buzard Opus 34
33 stops, 40 ranks

GREAT (4" wind)

16' Lieblich Gedeckt

8' Open Diapason

8' Flûte à Bibéron (wide chimneys)

8' Viola da Gamba

4' Principal

4' Spire Flute

22⁄3' Nazard

2 Fifteenth

13⁄5' Tierce

11⁄3' Mixture IV

8' Trompete

Tremulant

Cymbalstern

8' Festival Trumpet (Solo)

Great to Great 16', UO, 4'

Swell to Great 16', 8', 4'

Solo to Great 16', 8', 4'

SWELL (4" wind)

8' Violin Diapason

8' Stopped Diapason

8' Salicional

8' Voix Celeste (gg)

4' Principal

4' Harmonic Flute

2' Recorder

2' Full Mixture IV

16' Bassoon

8' Trompette

8' Oboe

4' Clarion

Tremulant

8' Festival Trumpet (Solo)

Swell to Swell 16', UO, 4'

Solo to Swell 8'

SOLO (4" wind)

8' Harmonic Flute

8' Flute Cœlestis II (Ludwigtone)

4' Open Flute

8' Clarinet

8' Festival Trumpet (horizontal)

Tremulant

Chimes

Solo to Solo 16', UO, 4'

Swell to Solo 16', 8', 4'

PEDAL (4" wind)

32' Subbass (1–12 digital)

32' Lieblich Gedeckt (1–12 digital) (Gt)

16' Open Diapason (in façade from FFF)

16' Bourdon (stoppered wood)

16' Gedeckt (Gt)

8' Principal

8' Bass Flute (ext 16')

8' Spire Flute

4' Choral Bass (ext 8')

4' Open Flute (ext 16')

16' Trombone

16' Bassoon (Sw)

8' Trumpet (ext 16')

8' Festival Trumpet (Solo)

Great to Pedal 8', 4'

Swell to Pedal 8', 4'

Solo to Pedal 8', 4'

Martin Ott Pipe Organ Company, St. Louis, Missouri

Opus 104: Zion Lutheran Church, Portland, Oregon


From the Organbuilder

In March of 2000, Mrs. Helen Hollenbeck, director of music at Zion Lutheran Church in Portland, Oregon, contacted our company about a new pipe organ. I was invited to come to Zion Lutheran Church to see the facilities and to meet with the organ committee.

In July of 2000, I visited Zion for the first time. I was impressed with the fine architecture of Pietro Belluschi—his design of the church is outstanding. At the time the new church was built, limited funds for a pipe organ were available. Zion decided to purchase a used organ. Mr. Belluschi installed this instrument on the choir balcony behind a radiating wall; the radius of this wall is 30 feet.

The organ committee, under the advice of their design architect, Mr. Joachim Grube of Portland, expressed their wish to keep the design of the new organ as Mr. Belluschi had originated. I agreed with the committee’s intention, and shortly after our meeting I submitted a proposal for the musical needs of Zion along with a visual design drawing. I kept the visual design simple but elegant. The new organ is now located again behind the radiating wall. A newly constructed organ chamber houses the organ apparatus and the pipes. The previous openings in the wall have been greatly enlarged, and the new organ case features the pipes of the Hauptwerk Prinzipal 8' and some pipes of the Pedal Oktavbass 8¢ exposed in the façade.

The layout of the divisions is symmetrical: the Great division is to the left and right side behind the façade pipes; the Swell division is centered above the keydesk of the organ; the Pedal division, which has the tallest pipes, is to the back of the organ chamber and centered behind the Swell division. The tonal design will support the strong musical tradition of the Lutheran church. The instrument is flexible and will be able to support congregational singing, choral anthems, and solo organ literature for preludes and postludes. The façade pipes are 75% tin, which contributes to the bright sound. The wooden pipes are made of poplar, spruce and mahogany.

We are especially grateful to the congregation for their enthusiasm and assistance. Many members spent a hot Sunday afternoon unloading the organ with our organ builders. We are thankful to the organ committee who facilitated the organ building process.


The following craftsmen participated in the construction of the organ for Zion Lutheran Church, Opus 104:


Alexander I. Bronitsky

James Cullen

William Dunaway

Eileen M. Gay

Bryan Hanlen

Alex D. Leshchenko

Richard Murphy

Martin Ott

Sascha Ott

Inna Sholka

Jeffrey Spitler

—Martin Ott

Orgelbaumeister

From the Director of Music and Organist

“You give it to them; they gather it; you open your hand, and they are filled with good things.” (Psalm 104:29)

As we gathered at Zion for the organ dedication, we were reminded of the many blessings that God showers upon us. We celebrated the gift of a new pipe organ—an instrument that will be used to praise God, lead His people in worship, give opportunity for teaching music and organ playing, and provide outreach to the Portland community. This was a huge undertaking for Zion Lutheran Church and, for most of us, a once in a lifetime experience.

When I became director of music and organist at Zion in 1998, I never dreamed that I would become involved in a pipe organ building project. What a journey it has been! The search committee spent hours researching and visiting instruments. There were endless meetings, much prayer, and lots of hard work needed to define the type of instrument that would best serve Zion’s congregation. One of the most critical elements was the historical nature of Zion’s building. The elegant simplicity of the Belluschi architecture would, without a doubt, become the inspiration for the design of the new organ case. Also, the tonal resources would need to be eclectic so that all styles of music—from Renaissance to the twenty-first century and beyond—could be played authentically. It was important that the organ live for the future, as well as for the past and present. With this in mind, the search went out to find a builder who would work with the specific needs of the Zion congregation. Martin Ott immediately connected with us by his understanding of Pietro Belluschi’s design philosophy.

I first became familiar with Martin Ott and his work when I attended the dedication of the two Ott pipe organs at the Mt. Angel Abbey in Mt. Angel, Oregon. Later, when I was preparing to complete work on my master’s degree, I chose to perform my graduate recital on the gallery organ at Mt. Angel Abbey Chapel. The Ott Opus 104 at Zion is just as inspiring and a great blessing to play.

It has been such a privilege to be part of this project. It took an enormous team effort. For this, I am grateful for the support and encouragement of Zion’s members and friends, as well as Zion’s pastors—Stephen Krueger, Paul Hilgendorf, and Ty Miles. I am also extremely thankful for the fundamental understanding that is present here at Zion, for the importance of music in the life of this congregation that was so critical to the building of this new organ. For all of this, God is to be praised and glorified! We have indeed been “filled with good things.”

—Helen Hollenbeck

From the Architect

I hope my work has gone unnoticed. As people experience the sound and sight of the new organ and appreciate the improved lighting and the renovated choir loft finishes I hope it never appears that any design work occurred.

It was the goal of the renovation plans to restore the design of the building’s original architect and to feature the work of the organ designer without introducing any additional aesthetic elements. A significant effort has been made by the design and construction teams to affect this transformation, but I hope this work appears transparent. I hope that the sanctuary will continue to be viewed as the work of Pietro Belluschi, now featuring an organ by Martin Ott.

Architectural consulting for this project was begun in 2000 by Joachim Grube of the Portland firm Yost Grube Hall. Mr. Grube collaborated with Pietro Belluschi in designing several Portland churches and has served Zion as a friend and advisor since Belluschi’s death in 1994. Mr. Grube assisted the congregation’s organ committee in selecting an organ design that would be complementary to the distinctive architectural character of the space. Following this preliminary planning, while the organ awaited fabrication, I began the work of planning and preparing the second floor of the sanctuary for the instrument’s arrival.

Renovation of the choir loft and organ chamber began following Easter services in 2005. Two weeks were spent removing hazardous materials that were used in the building’s original construction and following this abatement the rear wall of the choir loft was removed in order to extract the old organ. Marceau and Associates Pipe Organ Builders recovered all of the original pipes to be reused in other organs, while the largest rank of pipes was stored and reinstalled in our new instrument. Further demolition was done in the organ chamber before the curved wall was rebuilt in a configuration to accommodate the new organ.

Rebuilding these spaces provided an opportunity to improve lighting and accessibility of the choir loft for use in performances. The original risers were removed and the original tile floor finish was replaced to provide a uniform floor level allowing flexibility of movement by the choir and instrumentalists. A select group of original light fixtures was removed and replaced by improved fixtures and controls that will allow for multiple lighting scenes, which can be adjusted to complement varying musical arrangements.

Thank you to all of the members of the design, construction and organ building teams for your efforts and cooperation in providing this wonderful improvement to Zion’s worship space.

—Craig Rice, AIA

History of Zion’s New Organ

In 1999, the new organist/choir director and minister of music, Helen Hollenbeck, presented an evaluation of Zion’s current organ. Her personal experience with the instrument, in addition to her discussions with previous Zion organists, especially Tim Drews, pointed up major deficiencies in both the physical and musical quality of Zion’s pipe organ. Its condition had been deteriorating over the previous decade so that it was no longer possible to maintain it as the fine instrument it once was.
The board of trustees formed a committee to determine the possibility of getting a new organ for Zion. The question was whether Zion should purchase a used instrument, as it had done in the past, and attempt to fit it to our sanctuary, or contact a builder and have a new organ built to fit our needs and the marvelous acoustics of our church. In order to best serve the needs of the congregation, it was decided that a new organ be built, if possible.

The committee began to contact builders, not only in the Portland area, but also in the Northwest and in other areas of the country. Builders who expressed an interest in working with us were contacted. Not only did they come to Zion to see the building and experience its sound, but the committee in turn visited several of their instruments to see and hear how the organs fit their surroundings, both visually and musically. Because Zion is listed on the National Historic Registry, it was necessary that the builder produce an instrument to fit our musical and visual aesthetics as well as remain within our financial means.

Three organ builders were chosen and asked to submit proposals. The builder who seemed to fit us best in all categories was the Martin Ott Pipe Organ Company of St. Louis. In September 2001, the board was presented with the committee’s findings and at the same meeting they charged the committee to contract with Mr. Ott to begin work on the Zion instrument, to begin raising the money for the purchase of the new organ, and to handle the remodel of the balcony to accommodate the organ. Delays in fund-raising and getting approval from the State of Oregon for the renovations pushed back the date of the new instrument.

In spring of 2005, a contractor was engaged to work with Zion and Martin Ott Pipe Organ Company to assure that the balcony would accommodate the new instrument. The organ was delivered to the church on Sunday, June 5, and the congregation was there to greet it and help unload the thousands of pieces that make up this musical puzzle. Assembly began the very next day, June 6, 2005. Tonal finishing was begun on July 17 and the organ was consecrated to the Glory of God and the edification of all on Sunday, August 14, 2005.

The inaugural concert was played by David Dahl on September 30. Concerts continue this season: November 20, Helen Hollenbeck; February 19, Portland AGO chapter members; April 30, Tim and Nancy Nickel, Prokofiev: Peter and the Wolf; June 18, Jonas Nordwall.

—Charles P. Kovach

Chair, Zion Organ Committee

Ott Opus 104

30 stops, 40 ranks

HAUPTWERK

16' Bordun 56 pipes

8' Prinzipal 56 pipes

8' Rohrflöte 56 pipes

4' Oktave 56 pipes

4' Nachthorn 56 pipes

22/3' Quinte* 56 pipes

2' Oktave 56 pipes

13/5' Terz* 56 pipes

Mixtur IV 224 pipes

8' Trompete 56 pipes

Tremulant

SCHWELLWERK

8' Viola 56 pipes

8' Viola Celeste TC 44 pipes

8' Bordun 56 pipes

4' Prinzipal 56 pipes

4' Traversflöte 56 pipes

Kornett II TC 88 pipes

2' Flöte 56 pipes

11/3' Quinte 56 pipes

Mixture IV 224 pipes

16' Bombarde* 56 pipes

8' Trompette 56 pipes

8' Krummhorn 56 pipes

Tremulant

Zimbelstern

PEDAL

16' Offenbass 30 pipes

16' Subbass 30 pipes

8' Oktavbass 30 pipes

8' Pommer 22 pipes

4' Choralbass 30 pipes

Mixtur IV 120 pipes

16' Posaune 30 pipes

8' Trompete* 30 pipes



*prepared for

Couplers

HW/Ped with reversible thumb & toe pistons

SW/Ped with reversible thumb & toe pistons

SW/HW toe piston

Accessories

Attached keydesk, AGO standards

Case made of oak

Mechanical key action

Electric stop action

Combination action with 128 levels:

HW 1-2-3-4-5-6 thumb

SW 1-2-3-4-5-6 thumb

PED 1-2-3-4-5-6 thumb & toe

General 1-2-3-4-5-6-7-8 thumb & toe

Cancel–thumb

Set–thumb

Tutti–thumb & toe

Tuning after Fisk I

Martin Ott Pipe Organ Company, Inc., St. Louis, Missouri
Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church, Spring, Texas
Opus 68, b. 1991

From the builder
Trinity Lutheran is a large Missouri Synod Lutheran Church located in Spring, Texas, north of Houston. The area was settled by Germans who brought with them their Lutheran faith and customs. The church, founded in 1874, is still located on its original property. As the church has grown, sanctuaries have been removed and new ones have been built. In 1991, our Opus 68 began as the hope of Melvin Schiwart, the music director at the time. Mr. Schiwart had been to Germany. He wanted a good quality German organ for Trinity Church, and his search led him to our firm. A mechanical action organ with a detached console was designed. Although the organ has German influences, it is an eclectic instrument in style and adapts well to its American environment. In 1994, the 49-rank, 39-stop organ was installed in the previous sanctuary’s balcony.
The church membership grew through the 1990s, and the organ continued to be an important part of worship. As plans were made for a new sanctuary, the congregation decided to relocate the organ into the new church. Moving the instrument to the new space enabled the church to keep ties with their past. The organ and the church bell were the only items moved from the old church to the new one. The cost for moving the organ was a small fraction of what a new instrument would cost.
From the very beginning, our firm was invited to participate in the design of the new worship space, specifically the layout of the balcony. We worked with architect John Gabriel, of Gabriel Architects, Inc., and acoustician Scott Riedel, of Scott R. Riedel & Associates, Ltd. The new sanctuary has 44,000 square feet and seats 1,325 parishioners in the nave. Of special concern was how the existing organ could be best incorporated in the new building both visually and acoustically. The music is performed from the “west balcony” opposite the chancel with the altar, pulpit, baptismal font and lectern. Mr. Gabriel designed the large new balcony to accommodate the organ, the choirs, and the orchestral musicians. He was enthusiastic about the organ project and understood the physical and logistic needs. The overall design of the organ remained unchanged. Crown molding was added to give the instrument a stronger visual presence in the new room. We also have added a 32′ Bombarde, a 32′ Untersatz, and a Zimbelstern with a rotating star. As the instrument was reassembled, we thoroughly cleaned every part. The reed pipes were disassembled and completely cleaned before reassembly.
Trinity Lutheran was very enthusiastic about the project. During the weeks we spent reconstructing the organ and voicing, many parishioners would visit to see the progress. Among these visitors was singer-songwriter Lyle Lovett, born near Trinity Church, who asked us many questions about organ building. Mr. Lovett attended Texas A&M University where he studied journalism and German. He also spent time in Germany for his studies. Through his conversations with me, Mr. Lovett learned that the Ravinia Festival in Chicago owned an Ott portative organ; and at the July 12, 2008 concert at this festival, Mr. Lovett used the organ for several pieces in front of a full capacity audience.
The revoiced and visually altered instrument at Trinity Lutheran Church certainly brings vigor in sight and sound to this new sanctuary. We have many people to thank for their assistance in the project: Senior Pastor Richard Noack, Dr. William Brusick, Mr. Melvin Schiwart, and all of the Trinity Lutheran parishioners who were supportive and helpful. I would like to thank all who worked on Opus 68.
1994: John Albright, Albert Brass, James Fantasia, Jeffery Fantasia, Richard Murphy, Earl Naylor, Martin Ott, Thorsten Ott, Mary Welborn. On-site help: new choir risers designed by Jack Rimes, built by Gerhardt Pipho and Melvin Schiwart; riser banisters by Rick Davis; pipe shades in organ towers painted by Duane Schiwart.
2008: James Cullen, Bill Dunaway, Marya Fancey, Larry Leed, Aleksandr Leshchenko, Eileen McGuinn, Earl Naylor, Martin Ott, Inna Sholka. On-site help: Paul Jernigan, Shawn Sanders.
—Martin Ott
Martin Ott Pipe Organ Company

From the acoustical consultant
Trinity Lutheran approached Riedel for consultation in architectural acoustics and sound system design services in August 2001. Our goal for acoustic design was to develop a space that supports and enhances the Lutheran liturgy. Important considerations include reverberation period, HVAC noise control, noise control between spaces and from the outdoors, sound projection from the music area, support for musical ensemble and congregation hymn singing, and speech intelligibility.
The completed Trinity Lutheran sanctuary has a reverberation time, during unoccupied conditions, of 3.5 seconds. This generous reverberance provides excellent sound distribution and enhancement of organ and traditional choral tone. It also benefits Lutheran liturgical practices, encourages congregational sung and spoken participation, and gives a strong sense of listener envelopment.
Excellent speech intelligibility is achieved through innovative sound system technologies and careful design practices. Digitally steerable line array speakers provide very clear sound in this reverberant environment with minimal visual intrusion. A digital signal processor automates the system and replaces older multiple component technologies.
While the organ and traditional choir are an integral part of the congregation’s worship life, the growing use of contemporary instruments in Trinity Lutheran’s music ministry will necessitate a lower reverberation period at times. Treatment options have been presented to facilitate a more contemporary music service, and may be implemented by the client. These treatments include adding modest sound absorbing wall surfaces in select areas of the room.
A flutter echo reflection pattern is audible in the center aisle, resulting from the smooth, curved “barrel vault” ceiling profile favored by the architect. This curve focuses sound energy toward the center aisle of the room, such that the flutter effects are much less noticeable in the congregation seating areas. The overall room shape is cruciform, with organ and choir located at the end of the long axis of the space, in a rear gallery; this facilitates a full and even distribution of musical sound throughout the environment.
We are honored to be part of the Trinity Lutheran Church design team, and we are proud to have assisted in creating an environment that enhances the Ott organ, all in the service of the church.
—Scott Riedel
Scott R. Riedel & Associates, Ltd.

From the minister of music
In May 2007, I was blessed to receive a call from Trinity Lutheran Church in Spring, Texas. One month later, after serving as minister of music for fifteen years at Grace Lutheran in St. Petersburg, Florida, I accepted the call to Trinity. Like Grace, Trinity is a benchmark church in the community that puts a high value on the role of music in quality worship. Throughout the northwest Houston area, Trinity is known for its particular strength in traditional, liturgical worship. To this end, an instrument was sought that would be capable of leading and enhancing this style of worship. All roads inevitably led to Martin Ott.
I am blessed to be the recipient of the hopes, the dreams and the fortitude of a congregation and former minister of music who put such high value on quality music and the instrument that will lead it for generations. Although I had studied on a Holtkamp tracker organ, I had never had the privilege of playing a Martin Ott instrument until my pre-call interview in March 2007. The organ, located in the former sanctuary, looked and sounded spectacular; and yet, it was unfinished. The missing extensions of the two 32′ stops and the absence of any crown molding on the casework were testament to the inevitable expansion that still lay ahead. For myself, one who has been trained in and enjoys improvising on hymns and hymn tunes, the variety of colors and the wide dynamic range made this organ a especially thrilling instrument to play. As a composer, it is also fair to say that having an organ like this is like having a world-class orchestra at your disposal.
While the organ’s weekly mainstay is the leading of over a thousand worshippers in great works of hymnody, our music ministry also calls upon the organ to gently accompany a soloist, add equal support to a majestic brass choir, and blend into and uphold the mighty forces of a full orchestra and chorus. All of these our organ does effortlessly. In this way, I am confident that the Ott Opus 68 pipe organ can provide the style of high quality music that Trinity has come to expect and appreciate over its many years of great musical leadership.
But the blessings don’t end here. While it is a rare opportunity for an organist to meet the creators of their instrument, it is indeed even rarer to have the opportunity to work close at hand with them. Because of the relocation of the organ, I have had the distinct privilege of establishing a close-knit relationship with Martin Ott and his highly skilled team. Over the four months of planning and physically moving the organ, I began to see the care and craftsmanship and the sheer love that Martin has for his instruments and for the churches that will be led by them. During even the most stressful moments of the project, his focus and faith in the outcome never wavered. This instilled great comfort in all of us, knowing that the end result would be beyond everyone’s imagination.
As minister of music at Trinity Lutheran Church, I can speak for all when I say that we are indeed fortunate to have Martin Ott’s Opus 68, which has the potential to bring the highest level of both sacred and secular music to its listeners—leading worship, lifting song, inspiring creativity, enhancing the Word, and energizing the soul.
—William R. Brusick, D.Mus.
Minister of Music
Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church, Spring, Texas

From the pastor
The dream for a fine pipe organ at Trinity Lutheran Church began in the mid 1980s with our former (now retired) minister of music, Melvin Schiwart. His vision was that we would have a mechanical key action instrument ideally suited to lead robust congregational singing. In response to Mr. Schiwart’s leadership and vision, the congregation decided to establish a special organ fund to bring the project into reality.
Mr. Schiwart interviewed a number of leading organ builders in the United States and in Europe. In the early 1990s the congregation selected Martin Ott of St. Louis, Missouri, to design and build Trinity’s pipe organ.
Martin Ott’s Opus 68 was installed in our former sanctuary in 1994. In June 2008 it was moved into Trinity’s new 1425-seat sanctuary. The organ was expanded with additional stops and enhanced with beautiful casework.
The sanctuary has a classic basilica design and is constructed with internal surfaces that provide a rich reverberation. These features optimize the blessing that is the organ. Martin Luther commented that music often inspired him to preach. I must say that a rousing presentation by a capable organist of Ein feste Burg, At the Lamb’s High Feast We Sing or Crown Him with Many Crowns has definitely inspired my preaching on more than one occasion!
The wonderful marriage of our organ and our new building has yielded many blessings. Our current minister of music, Dr. William (Bill) Brusick, and our pastors enjoy our worship planning sessions. It is fun and energizing to find creative ways to maximize the impact of this superb instrument.
Leading worship in the Name of the Trinity is a high and holy calling. Our magnificent organ is integral to our worship and enhances our worship immensely. It is a great treasure and we are keenly aware that we must exercise faithful stewardship of it to the glory of Jesus Christ.
—Rev. Dr. Richard C. Noack
Senior Pastor
Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church, Spring, Texas

Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church, Spring, Texas
39 stops, 49 ranks, 4 extensions

HAUPTWERK (Manual II)
16′ Bordun 56 pipes oak
8′ Prinzipal 56 pipes 75% tin
8′ Rohrflöte (1–12 Bdn) 44 pipes 40% tin
4′ Oktave 56 pipes 75% tin
4′ Nachthorn 56 pipes 40% tin
22⁄3′ Quinte 56 pipes 50% tin
2′ Oktave 56 pipes 75% tin
Mixtur IV–V 255 pipes 75% tin
8′ Trompete 56 pipes 50% tin
8′ Horizontale Trompete 56 pipes 80% tin
4′ Schalmei 56 pipes 75% tin
Zimbelstern  5 Schulmerich bells

SCHWELLWERK (Manual III)
8′ Viola 56 pipes 50% tin
8′ Viola Celeste tc 44 pipes 50% tin
8′ Holzgedackt 56 pipes oak
4′ Prinzipal 56 pipes 50% tin
4′ Gemsflöte 56 pipes 40% tin
Sesquialter II mc 64 pipes 40% tin
2′ Oktave 56 pipes 50% tin
Scharf III–IV 214 pipes 75% tin
16′ Dulzian 56 pipes spruce
8′ Trompete 56 pipes 75% tin
Tremulant

POSITIV (Manual I)
8′ Holzprinzipal 56 pipes oak
8′ Bleigedackt 56 pipes 25% tin
4′ Rohrflöte 56 pipes 40% tin
22⁄3′ Nasat 56 pipes 50% tin
2′ Nachthorn 56 pipes 40% tin
13⁄5′ Terz 56 pipes 75% tin
11⁄3′ Quinte 56 pipes 75% tin
Zimbel III–IV 180 pipes 75% tin
8′ Krummhorn 56 pipes 50% tin
8′ Horizontale Trompete (from HW)
Tremulant

PEDAL
32′ Untersatz (ext Subbass) 12 pipes spruce
16′ Prinzipal 30 pipes 75% tin
16′ Subbass 30 pipes oak
8′ Oktavbass (ext Prinz 16′) 18 pipes 75% tin
8′ Pommer (ext Subbass) 12 pipes oak
4′ Choralbass 30 pipes 50% tin
Mixtur IV 120 pipes 75% tin
32′ Bombarde (ext16′) 12 pipes spruce
16′ Posaune 30 pipes spruce
8′ Trompete (from Hauptwerk)
4′ Schalmei (from Hauptwerk)

Couplers
Schwellwerk/Hauptwerk
Positiv/Hauptwerk
Schwellwerk/Pedal
Hauptwerk/Pedal
Positiv/Pedal

Aldo J. Baggia

Aldo J. Baggia is the retired chairman of the department of modern languages and instructor in French, Spanish, German and Italian at Phillips Exeter Academy in New Hampshire. He has studied and traveled extensively in Europe and has written numerous opera reviews for various publications as well as articles for The Diapason.

Niederrhein (Lower Rhine) is a small part of Westphalia that borders the Dutch cities of Arnhem and Nimegen, which had great importance in the Second World War because of their strategic locations as entrances to Germany. They are dealt with at great length in the well-known film, A Bridge Too Far. They are also culturally important because of their relationship with the towns of Niederrhein. Linguistically, one sees the relationship in the fact that the Dutch language is readily understood in the towns on the immediate border. It is very common for Dutch people to shop in a town such as Kleve, which is on the border, rather than in Holland, because the prices are better. It is normal to see the parking lot at the City Hall in Kleve with half of the cars having Dutch plates. When crossing into Holland, such as we did when going to ’s-Hertogenbosch to see the famous organ at Sint Jan’s Kathedraal, we saw very few cars besides our own with German plates.
The cathedral at Den Bosch is a magnificent gothic structure that dates from 1220, and the grand organ, III/48, with its Coptic oak case, dates from 1617, although it was not ready for use until 1622. Franz Symons, a carpenter from Den Bosch, and Georg Schysler, a sculptor from the Tirol, were responsible for the beautiful case. After work by various builders, the organ, which has 3,000 pipes, was completely restored in 1984 by Flentrop. The choir organ, II/29, by Verschueren, was installed in 1985. A recording by Jacques van den Dool shows the grand organ to very good effect in pieces by Bach, Reger, Messiaen, de Grigny, Guilain and van den Dool.1
Before going to Niederrhein, I tried to buy a guide book of the area in a large bookstore in the city of Bamberg. In the travel section, there were hosts of books dealing with what seemed to be every conceivable area of Germany, but, to my surprise, there were no guides of Niederrhein. I inquired at the desk and was told that there were no guides of Niederrhein because it was not a tourist area. I found this hard to believe, but had to accept the reality of the situation. Later, I did find a few guide books when I arrived in the city of Kleve, which, as mentioned previously, is right on the border with Holland. The whole area has towns that are quite similar, with an emphasis on pilgrimage churches (Wallfahrtkirchen) that serve as a common touch. The churches tend to be very large with good-sized organs and are the focal points of the towns.

Kevelaer
Kevelaer is the most famous pilgrimage place in Niederrhein, and its Marienbasilika has the largest organ in the area (IV/128). The town was bombed during the war, but not everything in the town center was destroyed, and the main street leading to the tower of the basilica looks as though it had not been touched for hundreds of years. The Marienbasilika organ originally had 124 stops, and additions were made in 1926, bringing the total to 131. At that time it received electric action, and a four-manual movable console was built. In the last days of World War II, the echo organ was destroyed, leaving the instrument with 110 stops. A restoration by Seifert in 1977 brought the organ of 10,000 pipes to its current total of 128 stops.2 The sound is quite dramatic because of the excellent acoustics that really enhance the power and majesty of the instrument. The recording mentioned in the endnotes features works by Reger, Liszt, Reubke (The 94th Psalm), and Karg-Elert. The airy quality of the sound is clear and leaves nothing to be desired.

Seifert & Sohn IV/128
Marienbasilika, Kevelaer
Unterwerk (I)
16' Pommer
8' Principal
8' Grobgedacht
4' Octave
4' Koppelflöte
2' Octävlein
2' Querpfeife
1-1/3' Spitzquinte
Sesquialter II
Scharff IV
Cymbel III
16' Cor anglais
8' Hautbois
Tremulant

Hauptwerk (II)
16' Principal
16' Bordun
8' Principal major
8' Principal
8' Fugara
8' Flaut major
8' Gamba
8' Gemshorn
8' Gedacht
8' Quinteviole
8' Doppelflöte
51'3? Quinte
4' Octave
4' Hohlflöte
4' Fugara
4' Flauto
4' Seraphon-Octave
3-1/5' Terz
2-2/3' Quinte
2' Octave
2' Flöte
1' Octavin
Cornett IV
Mixtur V
Scharff V
Rauschquinte II
16' Tuba
8' Trompete
4' Feldtrompete

Oberwerk (III)
16' Gedacht
8' Principal
8' Doppelgedacht
8' Rohrflöte
8' Flaut harmonique
8' Quintatön
8' Seraphon-Gamba
8' Cello
8' Dolce
8' Vox angelica
4' Octave
4' Rohrflöte
4' Violine
4' Flaut dolce
2-2/3' Nasard
2' Octave
2' Piccolo
1-3/5' Terz
Progressio III
Mixtur IV
Octavcymbel III
Scharff V
Rauschpfeife II
16' Fagott
8' Trompete
8' Clarinette
4' Schalmei

Schwellwerk (IV)
16' Lieblich gedacht
8' Principal
8' Geigenprincipal
8' Konzertflöte
8' Gedacht
8' Aeoline
8' Vox coelestis
8' Quintadena
4' Gemshorn
4' Traversflöte
4' Octave
4' Nachthorn
2-2/3' Quintflöte
2' Flautino
2' Superoctave
1-3/5' Terzflöte
1-1/3' Quinte
1' Sifflöte
Mixtur V
Carillon III
Terzcymbel III
Paletta III–VII
16' Tuba
8' Trompete
8' Krummhorn
8' Vox humana
4' Clairon
4' Celesta
Tremulant

Pedal
32' Contrabaß
32' Untersatz
16' Principalbaß
16' Octavbaß
16' Salicetbaß
16' Violon
16' Subbaß
16' Gedachtbaß
10-2/3' Quintbaß
8' Principal
8' Baßflöte
8' Dulciana
5-1/3' Quinte
4' Fugara
4' Octave
4' Flöte
2' Clarine
Mixtur VI

Hintersatz V
32' Bombarde
16' Posaune
16' Trompete
8' Trompete
8' Fagott
4' Clairon

Normal couplers
Crescendo
2 free combinations
Pedal combination
3 Tutti
Electropneumatic action
Source: Psallite CD 60131. Romantische Orgelmusik (an der großen Orgel der Marienbasilika zu Kevelaer – Orgelbau Romanus Seifert & Sohn)

Next to the basilica there is the Kerzenkapelle (the candle chapel), which has an outside collection of hundreds of candles that have been left by pilgrims. It includes an organ, II/28, which was originally installed in 1843, and rebuilt and cleaned by the firm Seifert & Sohn, which had moved to Kevelaer during the construction of the new organ for the Marienbasilika in 1906.3
The pilgrimages in honor of the Blessed Mother date from the middle of the seventeenth century, and the Kerzenkapelle was built during the years 1643–45. By the second half of the century there were from 18,000 to 20,000 pilgrims on feast days, and today Kevelaer is known as the largest pilgrimage center in northwestern Europe with over one million visitors per year.4
The organ of the parish church of Kevelaer, Sankt Antonius (III/42), was also built by the firm of Seifert & Sohn and dates from 1987. It has 2,915 pipes and benefits from the excellent acoustics of the church. This church was badly hit during World War II, but has been completely rebuilt in a manner that shows off its pre-war splendor.5

Xanten
One might wonder why a large cathedral was built in Xanten, a small town with the unusual name beginning in “X,” but its history is quite telling. In 15 B.C., the Romans built a large military camp called Castra Vetera I. This lasted until 69–71 A.D., when it was destroyed and replaced by Castra Vetera II. North of the military complex, a civilian settlement was planned and created in 105 A.D., with the name Colonia Ulpia Traiana, through the good graces of the emperor Marcus Ulpius Traianus. At the time, this was a fairly large area only 23 hectares smaller than the Colonia that was the provincial capital, known today as the city of Köln (Cologne).6
In October 1933, professor Walter Bader discovered two graves located in the present-day crypt that date from the years 348–350 A.D. They were identified as Christian soldiers in their thirties, who subsequently became the symbol of the strong faith of the people in this area.7 Martin Ahls indicated that the name “Xanten” is, in effect, a derivative from “Ad Sanctos,” which means “next to the saints.” He went further to answer his own question as to why a cathedral was built in this rather remote town on the Lower Rhine:

This question is answered when we go into the crypt. Although it is the most recent part of the cathedral, built after the excavations made in our century, it contains the very core of its history: the tomb of two Christians who were slain in the fourth century. This tomb of the Holy Martyrs is the center and the starting point of religion on the Lower Rhine and at the same time it is the key that helps us understand the construction of the cathedral and of the town: Here people wanted to pray and to live—next to the Saints. History gave the Martyrs a name: Viktor—the victor even beyond death.8
After the war, it was decided to add urns filled with ashes from the concentration camps of Auschwitz, Bergen-Belsen, and Dachau as memorials to all who suffered from the atrocities of the Nazi regime.9
The cathedral can be seen from afar, inasmuch as it is such a large edifice. The organ, III/45 with 3,293 pipes, is the largest that the cathedral has ever had and was built by Seifert & Sohn of Kevelaer in 1973–1975.10 The instrument has a free-standing case on the floor in the back of the church and can effectively play the repertoire from Bach through Messiaen. The symbolic nature of the cathedral is of paramount importance to the citizens of the town, and the restoration that was done after the severe damage of World War II fits in well with the original construction work. A curious aside is that Xanten is featured in the Nibelungenlied and was supposedly the birthplace of Siegfried.11

Seifert & Sohn, III/45
Dom St. Viktor, Xanten
Hauptwerk
16' Praestant
8' Prinzipal
8' Rohrpfeife
4' Oktave
4' Koppelflöte
2' Superoctave
Kornett V
2' Mixtur V
Cymbel III
16' Trompete franz.
8' Trompete franz.
4' Clairon

Schwellwerk
8' Holzflöte
8' Viola da gamba
8' Schwebung
4' Venezianerflöte
2-2/3' Nasat
2' Querflöte
1-3/5' Terz
1' Schwiegel
4/7' Septime
1-1/3' Mixtur IV
16' Basson
8' Hautbois
Tremulant

Rückpositiv
8' Metallgedacht
4' Prinzipal
4' Rohrflöte
2' Gemshorn
1-1/3' Quinte
Sesquialter II
Scharff V
8' Cromorne
Tremulant

Pedal
16' Prinzipal
16' Untersatz
102/3' Quintbaß
8' Oktavbaß
8' Rohrpommer
4' Choralbaß
4' Spitzgedacht
2' Nachthorn
5-1/3' Rauschwerk IV
2-2/3' Hintersatz V
16' Posaune
8' Trompete
4' Schalmei

Constructed 1973–1975
45 stops (3,293 pipes)
Mechanical key and stop action
Normal couplers, 3 free combinations, Pleno, Tutti
From the liner notes of Psallite CD 60161

Kleve
If one looks at a map, one can see how the towns of Niederrhein are interrelated; the concept of so many pilgrimage churches makes sense. Kleve, right on the Dutch border, suffered as much as the Dutch cities of Arnhem and Nimegen, the largest cities on the Dutch side. This area represented one of the Allied entry points into Germany, and it is quite clear that the towns on the German side suffered tremendously because of this.
A small book that was published in Kleve in 1964 alludes to one of the biggest problems the people in this area had.12 According to the author, “the British and Canadian troops advanced without having the slightest understanding of the many-sided problems a people living under a dictatorship had, and therefore on German soil they saw every German as a Nazi.”
The organ of the Stiftskirche or St. Mariä Himmelfahrt, III/45, was built by the Austrian firm Rieger in 1991 and is primarily used to accompany congregational singing during Mass. However, a recording by Martha Schuster playing romantic and post-romantic works shows what heights the organ can achieve.13 The case, as one can see, is quite modern. Kleve is known in legends as having a relationship with Lohengrin, who is certainly well known because of Wagner’s opera. A modern fountain in the pedestrian zone of the city shows a swan pulling at Lohengrin. The symbol of the city is the Schwanenburg (the Swan’s castle), which dominates the city along with the towers of the Stiftskirche nearby.

Rieger III/45
Stiftskirche St. Mariä Himmelfahrt, Kleve
Grand Orgue (I)
16' Montre
8' Montre
8' Flûte harmonique
8' Salicional
8' Bourdon
4' Prestant
2' Doublette
2' Fourniture IV
1' Cymbale III
8' Cornet V
16' Bombarde
8' Trompette
4' Clairon

Positif (expressive) (II)
8' Principal
8' Bourdon
4' Octave
4' Flûte douce
2-2/3' Nasard
2' Doublette
1-3/5' Tierce
1-1/3' Larigot
1' Plein jeu IV
8' Trompette
8' Clarinette
Tremblant

Récit Expressif (III)
16' Quintaton
8' Flûte traversière
8' Viole de Gambe
8' Voix céleste
4' Flûte octaviante
2' Octavin
III Carillon (2-2/3' + 1-3/5' + 1')
16' Tuba magna
8' Trompette harmonique
8' Basson-Hautbois
8' Voix humaine
4' Clairon harmonique
Tremblant

Pédale
32' Soubasse
16' Contrebasse
16' Soubasse
8' Basse
8' Bourdon
4' Flûte
32' Contrebombarde (ext)
16' Bombarde
8' Trompette

Mechanical key action
Electric stop action

Kalkar
Very near Kleve lies the small town of Kalkar, which profits from a quaint setting. The Nicolai Kirche’s intricately cut wood carvings make up much of the decoration that surrounds the different altars, as well as the elaborate casework of the organ (Seifert & Sohn, III/34). The first organ of the church dated from 1457, and from 1684 there was a baroque instrument. That was replaced in 1867–72 by a two-manual and pedal organ of 30 stops by the Rheinberg builder Bernhard Tibus (1815–1896). The Cologne architect Heinrich Wiethase designed a late-gothic case that is still in use today. Holger Brülls writes about this organ and the subsequent ones in an article cited below. One notes the influence of Aristide Cavaillé-Coll, and the Dombauinspektor (cathedral building inspector) Friedrich Schmidt praised the organ for its workmanship. The placement of the organ varied from the west tower to the south portal, where it is currently situated. The instrument was replaced in 1904 by Franz Tibus, but retained the Wiethase case. The two-manual and pedal organ on pneumatic cone chests was in line with German organ building of the late romantic years. In the late 1960s, Seifert & Sohn (Kevelaer) built an electric-action slider chest three-manual and pedal organ of a neo-baroque character and retained the Wiethase case. The organ has 2,450 pipes. It received some additions in the year 2000 during the course of interior renovation work in the church; two octave couplers and a new stop (Trompette-harmonique 8') were added. Jan Szopinski is the Cantor of St. Nicolai Kirche. Typical of the towns in the area, near the main square there is a picturesque windmill that was converted into a restaurant.14

Wesel
Driving directly west from Kleve, one encounters the city of Wesel, which has a very large Protestant cathedral (Dom) in the city center. The destruction during the war was substantial, and it is sad to see the pictures on display in the interior. It is a church of enormous scope, and the rebuilding was done over the span of many years, i.e., from 1947 to 1994, with the support of the Willibrordi-Dombauverein (Dom building association). The intent was to bring back the medieval nature of the Dom.15
The steeple stands high over the center of the town, and the only drawback is the fact that most of the windows are of plain glass. I don’t know what the situation was before the bombing, but there is no question that stained glass would have been extraordinary. It would have created a remarkable image in the interior because of the height of the windows. The organ, built by Marcussen & Søn of Denmark in 2000–2001 (III/54), is a very impressive instrument in a freestanding position in the west part of the church, and the case is striking. The acoustics are very good, and two recordings feature the instrument in repertoire from Buxtehude, Pachelbel, Bach, and Mozart through Franck, Mendelssohn, Reger, Brahms, and Messiaen. I found particularly impressive the Reger Introduction and Passacaglia in D minor, Boëllmann’s “Carillon” from Douze Pièces, and Dieu parmi nous by Messiaen.16

Marcussen & Søn III/54
Wesel Dom
Hauptwerk (II)
16' Prinzipal
8' Oktave I–III*
8' Hohlflöte
8' Rohrgedacht*
8' Gambe
4' Oktave I–III*
4' Spitzflöte
2-2/3' Quinte
2' Oktave I–III*
2' Waldflöte
Hintersatz VI–IX*
Scharf VI–VII
16' Trompete
8' Trompete
8' Spanische Trompete

Schwellwerk (III)
16' Rohrpommer*
8' Salizional
8' Voix céleste
8' Rohrflöte
8' Quintatön
4' Prestant*
4' Flüte octaviante
2-2/3' Nazard
2' Octavin
1-3/5' Tierce
Plein jeu V–VII
16' Basson*
8' Trompette
8' Vox humana
8' Oboe
4' Clairon

Rückpositiv (I)
16' Bordun*
8' Prinzipal
8' Gedacht
8' Spitzgambe*
4' Oktave*
4' Rohrflöte
2-2/3' Nasat
2' Gemshorn
Cornet II
Sesquialtera II*
1-1/3' Quinte
Mixtur V–VI
16' Dulzian*
8' Cromorne

Pedal
32' Untersatz*
32' Prinzipal*
16' Subbaß
8' Oktave
8' Spitzflöte
4' Oktave*
2' Nachthorn
Mixtur V*
16' Posaune
16' Fagott
8' Trompete

* all or partially made from pipes of the previous organ by Walcker

Bocholt
A very short distance from Wesel lies the city of Bocholt, which is in Westphalia but just outside the geographical limits of Niederrhein. The Liebfrauenkirche has a magnificent Klais organ, III/38, from 1979. I had been in touch with the Kantorin, Irmhild Abshoff, before going to Germany, and I knew something of its features from a recording that was issued in 1996 to commemorate 95 years of the parish’s work. When I arrived in Bocholt, the Kantorin was good enough to demonstrate the organ. There is no question that this is an extraordinary instrument capable of playing the entire repertoire for the organ. The recording opens with Bach’s Prelude and Fugue in G major, BWV 541, and the organ has a true baroque sound. The Kantorin also plays Karg-Elert’s Choralimprovisation für Orgel “Nun danket alle Gott,” which really shows the power and majesty of the instrument. It would be difficult to look for more. Bernhard Ratermann plays Franck’s Choral No. 2 in B minor, and here fonds d’orgue passages effectively contrast with a powerful reed-dominated tutti.17

Klais III/38
Liebfrauenkirche, Bocholt
Oberwerk (I)
8' Holzgedacht
8' Gamba
8' Unda maris
4' Principal
4' Traversflöte
2' Waldflöte
1-1/3' Larigot
2-2/3' Sesquialter II
2/3' Scharff IV
16' Basson Hautbois
8' Cromorne Trompete
Hauptwerk (II)
16' Quintade
8' Principal
8' Holzflöte
8' Gemshorn
4' Octave
4' Koppelflöte
2-2/3' Quinte
2' Superoctave
8' Cornet V
1-1/3' Mixtur IV
8' Trompete
4' Trompete

Brustwerk (III)
8' Rohrflöte
4' Blockflöte
2-2/3' Nasard
2' Principal
1-3/5' Terz
1' Sifflet
8' Vox humana

Pedal
16' Principal
8' Subbaß
8' Octave
8' Spielflöte
4' Tenoroctave
2-2/3' Rauschpfeife IV
16' Posaune
8' Holztrompete

6 couplers, 2 tremulants, 6 adjustable combinations
Mechanical key action, electric stop action

One could continue to visit other instruments in the area, but it is clear that this area is fairly typical of what one finds in Germany. The organ history in Germany is a long one and emphasizes the importance of music in the country.

 

Taylor & Boody Organbuilders, Staunton, Virginia

Goshen College, Goshen, Indiana

About the organ.

Designing an organ for Rieth Hall at Goshen College was a
pleasure. The opportunity to place the organ in the traditional location, high
in the rear gallery, was ideal both visually and aurally. The form and
proportions of the hall, with its austere yet warm and inviting interior,
called the organbuilder to respond with similar clarity and restraint. The
ample height of the room suggested a plain, vertical configuration of the
instrument, on which natural light from the clerestory windows would fall
gently. Everything about the hall spoke of its solid construction and honesty
of materials, qualities that we strive to reflect in our organs. Likewise the
acoustical properties of the hall, so warm and reverberant and at the same time
intimate and clear, allowed the organ’s tone to develop freely without
being forced. The result is an endearing musical instrument that is
aesthetically inseparable from the space in which it stands.

Initial inspiration for the Goshen case came from the organ
built by David Tannenberg in 1774 for Trinity Lutheran Church in Lancaster,
Pennsylvania. While only the case and façade pipes of that lovely
instrument have survived, they constitute the finest example we have in our
country of south German case architecture from the 18th century.
Tannenberg’s use of the double impost, with its Oberwerk division
gracefully placed as a reflection of the Hauptwerk below, was typical of organs
in his native Saxony and Thuringia. Other exterior influences from that time
and place include the two swags that bracket the center tower, and the broad
lower case that supports the full width of the impost and omits the spandrels
common to earlier styles. Apart from its simple springboard moldings, the
Goshen case is relatively flat and plain by comparison with its historical
counterparts. Its only bold three-dimensional element is the polygonal center
tower. The small pointed towers in Tannenberg’s design are here merely
implied by the V-shaped arrangement of foot lengths in the tenor fields. The
use of six auxiliary panels to raise the smaller pipe feet above the impost
moldings adds interest to the design. The considerable height of the lower case
was determined by the need for a passageway over the 2-foot concrete riser
behind the organ. This height gave space between the console and impost for the
eventual inclusion of a small Brustwerk with several stops for continuo
accompaniment. Cabinets for music storage are built into the back on both sides
of the lower case.

Another aspect of the design reminiscent of 18th-century
south German traditions is the position of the windchests in relation to the
action. The two windchests of the Hauptwerk are spaced apart from the center of
the case by the width of the keyboards. This leaves room for trackers of the
Oberwerk to reach their rollerboard without blocking access to the Hauptwerk
action and its pallets. It also provides optimum space for 8’ bass pipes
at the sides and leaves room for tuning the tenor pipes of the Hauptwerk with
only minimal obstruction by the Oberwerk rollerboard. The windchests for the
Pedal are located behind the case at the level of the impost, a placement that
Tannenberg could also have used.

Both the playing action and stop action are mechanical. The
manual keys are hinged at the tail and suspended from their trackers. There are
no thumper rails to hold the keys down, so they are free to overshoot slightly
when released, as is the case in traditional suspended actions. Trackers,
squares and rollers are all made of wood. There is no felt in the action. Keys
are guided by pins at the sides. Together these details combine to give a
feeling of buoyancy and liveliness reminiscent of antique instruments. The aim
is not so much to provide a light action as to arrive at one having the mass
and friction appropriate to the size and character of the organ. Such an action
may need occasional minor adjustment of key levels with changes in humidity,
but this is a small price to pay for the advantages gained over more sterile
modern alternatives. 

Wind is supplied by two single-fold wedge bellows (3’ x
6’) fed by a blower located in a small room below the organ. Natural
fluctuations of the wind pressure in response to the playing contribute to the
lively, singing quality of the organ’s sound. A wind stabilizer can be
engaged when unusually heavy demands on the wind system call for damping of
these fluctuations. The organ’s single tremulant is made in the old-fashioned
beater form. On seeing a tremulant puffing away in one of our organs, a
Japanese friend remarked that the organ was laughing! It is useful to think of
an organ’s wind as its breath and the bellows as lungs, for the
instrument’s appeal is closely tied to our perception of its lifelike
qualities. 

The tonal character of an organ is rarely revealed by its
stoplist. This is particularly true in an instrument of only twenty-four stops.
Once the builder accepts the constraints of a given style and the essential
registers have been chosen, there is usually little room or money left to
include stops that would make a modest design appear unique on paper.
Fortunately for the art, the musicality of the organ is not bound by its
stoplist; rather, it is determined by a host of other complex factors. These
can be partially defined in the technical data of pipe scaling and
construction, general design parameters, materials and the like, but in reality
much more rests on the elusive criteria of experience, skill and taste of the
builder. Taken together this means that each new organ, albeit small, presents
fresh opportunities for artistic expression. It is important that all the pipes
speak promptly, be they reeds or flues, except in the case of strings, which
gain charm from their halting speech. It is less important that the pipes
produce precisely the same vowel sounds from note to note, for here variety
adds refreshing character and interest to the organ.

At Goshen we chose to voice the 8’ Principal to be
somewhat brighter and richer in overtones than has been our wont. This was
achieved by giving the pipes lower cutups than was customary in German and
Dutch organs of the 17th century and before. The five distinctly different
8’ flue stops on the manuals deserve special mention. Although all
followed scaling patterns we have used frequently in the past, when voiced they
proved to be unusually satisfying, particularly in combination with each other.
Whenever the 16’ Bordun is used with them a magical new dimension is added
to the sound. If, for example, one draws the Bordun with the Viol da Gamba, the
effect is that of a quiet 16’ Principal. Used with the Spillpfeife the
Bordun reverts to its role as a flute. In an organ of this size it is crucial
that every stop work as well as possible with every other. Following south
German practice, both 8’ and 4’ flutes on the Hauptwerk are made in
the same form. This duplication of flutes within the same family was not the
custom in the north, where lower pitched flutes were usually stopped and those
above them progressively more open. The Oberwerk configuration at Goshen with
its two stopped 8’ registers and partially open 4’ Rohrflöte is
typical of the northern tradition. We look forward to the day that the 16’
Violonbass with its cello-like speech can be added to the Pedal.
style="mso-spacerun: yes"> 

The distinctive musical effect of the Goshen organ is
strongly colored by the use of the recently released Bach-Lehman temperament
described in the accompanying article. Because the completion of the organ in
February coincided with the publication in Early Music of Bradley
Lehman’s treatise on J. S. Bach’s temperament, we chose to tune the
organ according to his plan. Here was the ideal opportunity to try the
temperament on an organ built in Germanic style and at the same time to honor
Dr. Lehman as a distinguished Goshen alumnus for his work in this field. The
experiment has been a fascinating one. It has provided a place to hear
Bach’s organ music as we have not heard it before. We are honored to have
played a part in translating the dry mathematical numbers of this temperament
into the vibrant sound of the organ. 

With few exceptions the many parts of the organ were
constructed from raw materials in our Virginia workshop. Through the skills of
each craftsman the design moved from an idea to paper and then through raw wood
and metal into a large and impressive object. Note by note the tonal picture
has been filled in by voicing and tuning until in the end we experience a new
instrument with an identity all its own. We hope that it will give pleasure to
those who play and hear it far into the future.

--George Taylor

The organ project at Goshen College

“Dienlich, Ordentlich, Schicklich, Dauerlich”

In 1999 we were asked by the organ consultant for Goshen
College, Roseann Penner Kaufman, to make a proposal for the new Goshen College
Music Center. As with any new project, I went to Goshen full of excitement at
the promise of participating in what was to be a spectacular project. My
enthusiasm was short-lived when I saw the design for the recital hall. It was a
standard fan-shaped, sloped-floor, small college recital hall, with theatre
seats and carpet in the aisles. The space for the organ was planned in a niche
at the back of the stage. The design would have been fine for small chamber
recitals, but it was not a proper home for an organ. The prospects for the
organ looked bleak. We would not have felt productive or inspired. We always
say that the room is more than half the organ. I took a deep breath and told
the Goshen committee what I thought of the plan. The committee listened and
asked us to offer suggestions on how the recital hall might be designed to work
best with the musical programs envisioned for this space.

I returned to Staunton eager to develop a plan. One of the
first things I did was to research the Mennonite Quarterly Review for articles
describing historical Anabaptist worship spaces. I hoped that the essence of
these rooms would lead me to an aesthetic that would tie the new hall to the
old tradition, which would, in turn, also be good for music, especially the
organ. My research acquainted me with four German words used to express the
qualities of the historical spaces: dienlich, ordentlich, schicklich and
dauerlich--serviceable, orderly, fitting and lasting. I also found prints
of the interiors of some of these churches. Rectangular in shape with open
truss timber roof framing, clear glass windows, galleries on several sides,
rough stone floors, moveable chairs, unadorned, honest and powerful, these
spaces had all the qualities that I was looking for. They also had enduring
musical-acoustical qualities and so many are used today for concerts.

The simple sketch that I made went first to the Goshen organ
committee who, led by Doyle Preheim and Chris Thogersen, embraced the plan.
Then the concept went to Rick Talaske and his team of acousticians. They
transformed the plan into practical geometry and surface treatments to make the
space an acoustical success. Mathes Brierre Architects took the acoustical plan
and translated it into a visual design that evokes the warehouse or
brewery-turned-church concept of the early Dutch Mennonite spaces. Schmidt
Associates worked through the technical details with Casteel Construction to
conceive the simple pre-cast concrete panels and graceful curved steel arches
that make the hall appealing in its architecture, superior in acoustical
performance and straightforward and durable in construction. There was creative
and sensitive work done by a Goshen group concerned with decor and furnishings.
The result is successful beyond our expectations. The collaboration of all the
partners made the project exceed the ability of any one of us.

Once the hall was underway, we scheduled a meeting at St.
Thomas Fifth Avenue in New York with a group from Goshen and Calvin and Janet
High from Lancaster, Pennsylvania. We had a great day in New York showing
everyone our organ in the gallery of St. Thomas. The Highs’ enthusiasm
for the St. Thomas organ and the Goshen Music Center paved the way for their
generous gift that underwrote the cost of the organ.

We realized that the floor area of Rieth Hall was small in
relation to the height. We saw that if there could be the addition of one more
bay to the length there would be significant improvement in the proportions of
the space and at least 50 more seats could be added. Again, the Goshen design
group supported our suggestion. At a time in the project when the building
committee was attempting to control costs and squeeze performance out of every
dime, they found the funds for this most important late addition.
style="mso-spacerun: yes"> 

I predicted at the time we were creating the designs for
Rieth Hall, that the unique qualities of this space would have something to say
to the Goshen students about music and worship. This prediction has been
realized. First, there is genuine enthusiasm for a cappella singing in Rieth
Hall, encouraging this wonderful Mennonite tradition. Second, there has been a
spontaneous seizing of the space by the students for their own student-directed
Sunday worship. In this age of searching for the right path in worship and
liturgy, of debating the influence and appropriateness of mass media and
popular music for worship, we have built something at Goshen College that
reaches across the span of time to those Mennonite roots. Led by the seemingly
old-fashioned qualities of dienlich, ordentlich, schicklich and dauerlich, we
have made a  music space and organ
that inspire and excite us to make music and to celebrate and serve our God and
Creator.

Wood and the Goshen organ

The traditional pipe organ is a wooden machine. Early on in
our careers as organ builders we realized that getting control over our
materials in both an aesthetic and technical sense was essential to our success
as organ makers. Our first path was to make friends with our neighborhood
sawmillers. One of these was an octogenarian whose experience reached back to
horse logging and steam power. He taught us the value of long, slow, air-drying
of lumber. He also knew the old traditions of sawing, how to take the tension
out of a log, how to saw through the middle of the log and keep the boards in
order so that the cabinetmaker could match the grain. He remembered the methods
of quarter sawing that impart the most dimensional stability to the boards and
in oak bring out the beautiful fleck of the medullary rays. We have built our
own sawmill based on a portable band saw. For quarter sawing, we have built a
double-ended chain saw that can split logs up to 60 inches in diameter. The
half logs (or quarters in extremely large timber) are then aligned on our band
saw and sawn in a radial fashion into boards. This lumber is then air-dried for
a number of years. At the end, we put the wood in our dry kiln and gently warm
it up to stabilize the moisture content at 8% to 10%.

Oak is the traditional wood of Northern European organ
building so it was natural for us to choose white oak for the Goshen organ. We
have long admired the Dutch and German organs dating back to the 16th century.
The earliest organs show only the natural patina of age and no finish; the
concept of finishing wood as in varnishing or oiling came well into the 18th
century. We followed this earlier practice for the Goshen organ. The oak has
been hand-planed to a smooth polish, much smoother than can ordinarily be
produced with sanding. The hand-planed wood will resist dirt. We feel there are
also musical benefits from using wood in its natural state. The case and
carvings together with all the interior parts transmit sound energy and reflect
and focus the sound of the pipes. Also, the open pores and surface
imperfections of the natural wood have an effect on the sound reflection.

Another aspect of wood use in historic organs is how
efficiently the old builders utilized their wood. Before the age of machinery,
cutting, transporting and converting timber to sawn, dried lumber ready for use
was costly. The best wood was always used for the keyboards, playing action,
wind chests and pipes. The next selection went to the most visible parts of the
case, especially the front of the organ. The rest was used for carvings, heavy
structural members, walkways, bellows framework and back panels. Some of this
wood shows knots, cracks and other defects that might offend our modern sense
of perfection. However, in addition to demonstrating good wood utilization, the
varying density and differences in surface texture of these so-called defects
may indeed benefit the music. How we perceive the sound of an organ is a very
complex and subtle equation. This is one of the wonderful aspects of the real
pipe organ that differentiates it from the sterile sound of the electronic
substitute. We feel it is good stewardship to apply the hierarchy of selection
as practiced by the old masters. We try to use all the wood, through careful
selection, with thoughtful conservation of a vanishing resource.

--John Boody

Acoustic design of Rieth Recital Hall at Goshen College

In 1998, the design team of design architect Mathes Group
(now Mathes Brierre Architects), architect of record Schmidt Associates and
acoustician The Talaske Group (now Talaske) began preliminary work on a new
music education and performance building for Goshen College’s campus.
This project was the College’s greatest building investment to date and
they were determined to do things right . . . with a very modest budget. The
Recital Hall (now Rieth Recital Hall) was slated to house a new tracker organ
of exceptional quality. As acousticians, we offered some general planning
recommendations--not the least of which was a 50-foot ceiling
height--and recommended that the organ builder be hired as soon as
possible.

Enter John Boody of Taylor & Boody, organ builders from
Virginia. John energized the subsequent meetings with some profound advice that
proved to set the final direction for the space. He moved our thinking from a
“fixed” seating configuration to a flexible arrangement based on a
flat floor where seats can face either end of the room. This unique concept
facilitated the accommodation of a conventional “recital hall” or
assembly arrangement with musicians or presenters on a small stage. The cleverness
of the concept is the seats can be turned to face the opposite direction in the
room, offering a classic organ recital arrangement. Furthermore, John
recommended that the proportions of the room would be better served if
lengthened by adding another bay of structure. These fundamental planning ideas
changed the direction of the design in perpetuity.

We embraced these new directions yes">  and identified the many other room acoustics design features
that would support the client’s needs. The 50-foot ceiling height remained,
and we worked with the architects and construction manager to render the room
as a sound-reflective concrete enclosure, embellished with wood. The goal was
to maintain the warmth of sound created by the organ. Within the “theatre
planning” process, we guided and exploited naturally occurring
opportunities for introducing sound diffusing shaping to reflect low- and
mid-pitched sound in all directions--by introducing one side balcony and a
rear balcony, recesses from circulation paths and recesses created by
deeply-set windows. We recommended deliberate articulation of the walls to
diffuse mid- and high-pitched sound. Wood surfaces were detailed to minimize
absorption of low-pitched sound. Retractable velour curtains and banners were
recommended in abundance and specified by Bob Davis, theatre consultant.
Architecturally, curtain and banner pockets were created so the sound-absorbing
materials could be retracted completely on demand. These features make possible
a broad “swing” of the sound of the room from very reverberant for
choral and organ performance to articulate for assembly events or amplified
music performance. Fundamental to the acoustic design was the need for silence.
This was accomplished by structural discontinuities in the building (acoustic
isolation joints) and the proper placement and design of heating and air
conditioning systems.

Within their mission statement, Goshen College states:
“Musical expression is a human manifestation of the divine impulse and,
as such, serves as a window into the individual soul, a bridge between human
beings and a means of corporate religious experience.” In light of the
students adopting the Rieth Recital Hall for their weekly convocations and the
many other uses, we are pleased to say the happy story continues!

--Rick Talaske

Bach temperament

This organ is the first since the 18th century to use Johann
Sebastian Bach’s tuning, as notated by him in 1722 on the title page of
the Well-Tempered Clavier. This tuning method is a 2004 discovery by Bradley
Lehman. The article about this discovery is published in the February and May
2005 issues of Early Music (Oxford University Press), and further details are
at <www.larips.com&gt;.

The layout, dividing the Pythagorean comma, is:

F-C-G-D-A-E = 1/6 comma narrow 5ths;

E-B-F#-C# = pure 5ths;

C#-G#-D#-A# = 1/12 comma narrow 5ths;

A#-F = a residual wide 1/12 comma 5th.

In this tuning, every major scale and minor scale sounds
different from every other, due to the subtle differences of size among the
tones and semitones. This allows music to project a different mood or character
in each melodic and harmonic context, with a pleasing range of expressive
variety as it goes along. It builds drama into musical modulations.
style="mso-spacerun: yes"> 

The result sounds almost like equal temperament, and it similarly
allows all keys to be used without problem, but it has much more personality
and color. In scales and triads it sounds plain and gentle around C major (most
like regular 1/6 comma temperament), mellower and warmer in the flat keys such
as A-flat major (most like equal temperament), and especially bright and
exciting in the sharp keys around E major (like Pythagorean tuning, with pure
fifths). Everything is smoothly blended from these three competing systems,
emerging with an emphasis on melodic suavity.

The following chart shows the relative size of each major
third, resulting from each series of the intervening four fifths. This system
of analysis is from the 1770s, published in the theoretical work of G. A. Sorge
who was a former colleague of Bach’s. The intervals having higher numbers
sound spicier, more restless. In this measurement, a value of 11 would indicate
a major third that is one syntonic comma too sharp (a “Pythagorean major
third,” having been generated by four pure fifths).
style="mso-spacerun: yes">  A pure major third would be represented
here as 0.

Bb-D    6
style='mso-tab-count:1'>             D-F#
    7
style='mso-tab-count:1'>             F#-A#
8

Eb-G    7
style='mso-tab-count:1'>             G-B
      5
style='mso-tab-count:1'>             B-D#
   9

Ab-C    8
style='mso-tab-count:1'>             C-E
       3
style='mso-tab-count:1'>             E-G#
   10

Db-F     9
             F-A
       3
style='mso-tab-count:1'>             A-C#
   9

Equal temperament, as opposed to the variety shown here, has
a constant size of 7 in all twelve of the major thirds.

In functional harmony, the Bach tuning sets up especially
interesting contrasts within minor-key music. The key of A minor has the
plainest tonic juxtaposed with the most restless dominant. F minor, a major
third away, has the opposite relationship: troubled tonic, calm dominant. And
C# minor has the average character between these behaviors, where the tonic and
dominant are both moderately energetic. 

In major-key music, the tonics and dominants have characters
similar to one another. The sizes of major thirds change by only 1, 2, or 3
units from each key to its neighbors, moving by the circle of fifths (through
typical subdominant/tonic/dominant progressions). Any change of Affekt is
therefore gradual and subtle, as if we never really leave the home key
altogether but it feels a little more or less tense as we go along.

In any music that modulates more quickly by bypassing such a
normal circle-of-fifths cycle, the contrasts are momentarily startling. That
is, the music’s dramatic harmonic gestures become immediately noticeable,
where the major thirds have changed size suddenly from one harmony to the next.
This comes up for example in the Fantasia in G Minor (BWV 542), Gelobet seist
du, Jesu Christ (BWV 722), and the fourth Duetto (BWV 805), and especially in
music by the Bach sons.

This system turns out to be an excellent tuning solution to
play all music, both before and after Bach’s. It is moderate enough for
complete enharmonic freedom, but also unequal enough to sound directional and
exciting in the tensions and resolutions of tonal music.

A recording will be ready for release this summer, including
music by Bach, Fischer, Brahms, et al.

--Bradley Lehman

A brief history of the organ in the Mennonite Church

Some people might find it unusual to find such a remarkable
organ in a Mennonite college. Aren’t the Mennonites those folks with the
buggies and suspenders? It is true that some Mennonite congregations still take
literally founder Menno Simons’ caution against the organ as a
“worldly” invention, but most, especially in the last fifty years,
have embraced it as a vital contributor to the musical and worship life of the
community. 

The Mennonite Church has its beginnings in the 16th-century
Protestant Reformation. Because of persecution, most of the early worship
services were held secretly, in homes or out-of-the-way places. Mennonites also
believed that the true church existed in small, simple gatherings; therefore,
it was uncommon for early Mennonites to even set aside a separate building for
worship. 

Two hundred years after the beginning of the movement,
churches in Germany and the Netherlands had grown to the point of meeting in
dedicated buildings, and by the 1760s several in urban areas had installed pipe
organs. It was another two hundred years, however, before organs became common
in the Mennonite conference that supported Goshen College. Even now, the organ
is not necessarily assumed to support congregational singing, but contributes
other service music. Organ study is now offered at all of the Mennonite Church
USA-affiliated colleges, and the new Taylor & Boody organ at Goshen will
certainly have a profound impact on the future of worship and organ study
throughout the denomination.

--Roseann Penner Kaufman

Roseann Penner Kaufman, DMA, is adjunct instructor in organ
at Bethel College, N. Newton, Kansas, a four-year liberal arts college
affiliated with the Mennonite Church USA. She also serves as director of music
for Rainbow Mennonite Church in Kansas City, Kansas. Dr. Kaufman served as the
consultant to Goshen College for their organ project.

Specifications for Opus 41

Hauptwerk

16' Bordun (C-D# wood, rest metal*)

8' Principal (77% tin)

8' Spillpfeife

8' Viol da Gamba (77% tin)

4' Octave

4' Spitzflöte

3' Quinte

3' Nasat

2' Superoctave

IV-V Mixtur

8' Trompet

Oberwerk

8' Gedackt (99% lead)

8' Quintadena

4' Principal (77% tin)

4' Rohrflöte

2' Waldflöte

II Sesquialtera

IV Scharff

8' Dulcian

Pedal

16' Subbass (wood)

(16' Violonbass) space prepared

8' Octave

4' Octave

16' Posaune (C-B wood, rest 99% lead)

8' Trompet (99% lead)

Couplers

Oberwerk / Hauptwerk

Hauptwerk / Pedal

Oberwerk / Pedal

Tremulant to entire organ

Mechanical key and stop action

Compass: manual 56 notes C-g''', pedal 30 notes C-f'

Lehman-Bach temperament

Interior metal pipes of hammered alloys

*All unmarked metal alloys of 28% tin, 72% lead

Case of solid white oak

Windchests of solid oak, pine & poplar

Number of pipes: 1604

Wind pressure: 75mm

Wind stabilizer

The builders

George K. Taylor

John H. Boody

Bruce Shull

Emerson Willard

Christopher A. Bono

Kelley Blanton

Chris A. Peterson

Sarah Grove-Humphries

Robbie Lawson

Jeffrey M. Peterson

Larry J. Damico

Holly Regi

Thomas M. Karaffa

Bob Harris

Katie Masincup

Ryan M. Albashian

Kristin E. Boo