Parsons Pipe Organ Builders, Canandaigua, New York; Saint Benedict Cathedral, Evansville, Indiana
Given the opportunity for a major instrument in a large Catholic cathedral with superb acoustics, most builders might be forgiven for playing to type. These acoustics and this liturgy implies something French in nature, no? We know the great legacy the French have given to music and Catholicism; surely one thing follows another. And yet our Opus 52 for Saint Benedict Cathedral in Evansville, Indiana, had a different genesis and, in the end, a result well apart from the above pattern. The process, and the result, has been not merely a pleasant surprise, but—this project has proved to us—the right instrument for this place and these people.
Our first encounter with Saint Benedict’s contemplated a modest reworking of their 1930s Wicks. That first visit allowed us to be impressed by the opportunity before us. The parish of Saint Benedict was established in 1912, placed in pastoral care of the monks of Saint Meinrad Archabbey (which organists know today for the fine Goulding & Wood organ there). Designed in Lombard Basilica form, the edifice is grand: 150 feet long, 65 feet wide, and 63 feet tall. When completed in 1928 the ceiling was fitted with sound-attenuating Celotex tiles. In 1934, when it became possible to afford an organ, the parish acquired a two-manual, 20-rank Wicks, Opus 2367. In the practice of many 20th-century Catholic churches, the organ was divided in cases to either side of the rear window, with choir seating in between. This arrangement was never satisfactory, as the choir was buried between the organ cases yet unable to hear it clearly or project properly. A renovation in 2019 improved the acoustics and enlarged the gallery to accommodate sizable musical forces and a significant pipe organ.
As discussions continued, the original rebuilding idea gave way to a new three-manual organ, with a nave section to accompany singers up front. Still, the stoplist remained economical in feel until the already-generous lead donors decided they could do even more. Embellishments included a second fanfare reed, a full-length 32′ Trombone to join the open 32′ Contrebasse, and strengthened manual flute and principal choruses throughout.
Certain choices formed around vintage material, reworked along our musical ideals while still disclosing their heritage. Although the 1934 Wicks was a modest instrument, its musical content was distinctive. Wicks’s tonal director at this time, Henry Vincent Willis (a grandson of Father Willis and first cousin to Henry Willis III), evolved a version of late English Romantic heroic voicing much in the vein of Richard Whitelegg at M. P. Möller in the same period. With reconditioning, re-voicing, and upperwork, these pipes form the strong unenclosed Great chorus at the organ’s core. Additionally, the parish acquired a 1937 Austin from First Unitarian Church, Oakland, California, designed by James B. Jamison. Jamison’s ideals were in line with Willis’s; the Swell chorus fuses Wicks and Austin material (again revoiced and rebalanced) to match the Great’s in similar style. Fully winded and copiously nicked, these pipes sing with bright but not overdone trebles. The Mixture, expanded to four ranks, is especially silvery without being so loud as to complicate choral accompaniment.
Sharing an enclosure, the enclosed Great/Choir takes the design in different directions. The Harmonic and Spitz flutes are the expected Great registers, with the benefit of expression and joined to the organ’s boldest strings. The Gamba fills out the Great foundations; with its celeste, the two cap the string ensemble as a Solo pair might. The Choir’s foundations—the reedy Violin Diapason and stringy Fugara, of tapered construction—find kinship with the Great and Swell. The Choir 2′ Principal and III Mixture are the organ’s leanest; the chorus here can be based just as effectively on the 8′ Bourdon in the neoclassical manner. In contrast to the liquid tones of the Swell’s, the Choir’s flutes are more pointed and focused, balanced so that any combination makes sense while remaining clear. The mild color reeds top this ensemble, particularly with the woody 16′ Clarinet Bass underneath.
Finally, we had the luxury of providing Pedal flues with the range of clarity and depth a large organ requires, from the soft, ultra-clear Gemshorn to a pervading Open Wood whose treble range offers solo potential. The narrow-scale wood 32′ Contrebasse is a flexible chameleon, purring quietly alone while growing stronger as more 16′ tone is added.
The nave section is designed on the unit principle, something we generally avoid but seemed warranted here, given limited space coupled to a purely accompanimental program at this end of the cathedral. The Diapason is the organ’s leanest; an independent Twelfth is critical to a plausible-sounding chorus “effect.” Other ranks provide support at various levels of color and dynamic. The shimmering Unda Maris leads to the organ’s other soft celestes and beyond, and is especially ravishing as it disappears to celestial near-inaudibility. Formed from both open wood and metal pipes, the Concert Flute is a room-filling voice and becomes particularly emotional with tremolo. The Flügelhorn, of Skinner pattern but with harmonic trebles, is a do-everything stop, lyrical in solo and compelling in chorus. The pointed Pontifical Trumpet lies in between the Great/Pedal Bombarde and the Tuba. Thanks to the Opus-Two system and some invisible coupling intelligence, one can readily dialogue the Tuba and Pontifical Trumpet against the tutti.
Given the strength of the flue choruses, the chorus reeds might be unexpected: solidly English, yet not even at the power of where chorus reeds tend to fall in actual English instruments. Here again, the pre-existence of Wicks and Austin trumpets led us away from the overt and towards a mild grandeur, a recipe that ended up being superior for vocal support. This idea lines up nicely with where our organs have headed for several years now: organs that lead without competing, focused principally on Sunday morning without forgetting the occasional Saturday recital.
And it’s important to remember where we were: a Roman Catholic cathedral not in Paris or Toulouse, but firmly in the heartland of southwest Indiana. The music here spans the gamut, and an organ must take its accompanimental role not casually but with true seriousness. Tempting as such a space might compel one to blaze away with Trompettes and Cornets, those sounds would be largely antithetical to this organ’s core role: standing by one voice or a hundred, in sanctuary or gallery, helping singers to match pitch, with a measured treble ascendancy that stays clear without overwhelming the voices any organ hopes to lead.
In that regard, these darker reeds revealed themselves as assets, and with a sheer grandeur of tone compelling in their own right. The Austin chorus, reconceived and rebuilt by Christopher Broome, follows an early-20th-century English pattern: a 16′ Fagotto rich in heavy cream; a snappier but still well-bred 8′; a 4′ in between the others. The resolutely American-type Oboe makes a logical partner to the trumpet family. How these four reeds are balanced makes possible any number of lesser full swells, together with orchestral potential in coupling the Fagotto to either of the chipper 4′ and 2′ harmonic flutes. Even the Fagotto and Mixture by themselves make a convincing ensemble. A similar ideology is at work in the enclosed Great, where the Full Mixture—a one-stop chorus that gains an 8′ at middle C—fuses with those Trumpets as an alternative full Swell on the other side of the gallery.
Approaching the tutti, however, it seemed desirable that certain reeds rise to meet the power of the fluework and the grandeur of the space. The Pedal Bombarde is primarily a bass melody stop loosely in the French manner; its availability on the Great allows for occasional climaxes beyond the other reeds. The Pontifical Trumpet augments the ensemble further, especially when introduced behind closed shutters. These stops lead up to the magnificent Choir Tuba. Built by Shires in England, voiced by Christopher Broome, and placed directly behind the shutters, it offers clang and brawn in equal measure. The 32′ Trombone, extended from the Great double, is intentionally not dominating. Enclosure augments its usefulness in accompaniment.
As the organ design evolved, the cathedral’s musical team was keen to point out the problems of the old arrangement. Our instrument is in one large case against the rear wall, exposed to frame the central stained glass window by F. X. Zettler Studios of Munich. In this arrangement, the choir can hear both organ and themselves more clearly than ever. The unenclosed Great sits in the open center, on windchests so arranged as to be concealed by the case posts. One level down are Pedal trebles; behind both levels, the 32′ Contrebasse is stacked horizontally against the rear wall. The Swell stands in a large enclosure on the right, with the enclosed Great/Choir in a similar chamber on the left. The chassis is largely traditional, with slider chests for the main departments fed by a copious wind supply with wedge bellows. Single-note actions are employed for extended registers and those of higher pressure. The nave section is in a newly formed chamber behind a non-speaking façade. Built by J. Zamberlan & Co. and finished in our shop, the identical consoles were kept as simple as possible, with seven divisions over three, not four manuals. Various transfer couplers add flexibility for the nave and enclosed Great. Storage is abundant, with a pullout drawer beneath the manuals and music cabinets built into either side.
In designing our instruments, a chief goal is to make every pipe and mechanism easily reached for tuning and maintenance. Our designer Peter Geise works closely with Travis Tones and Ric Parsons to work out, refine, alter, and finalize every pathway inside any organ. (The saddest sound from any organ comes from tuners needlessly bonking their heads.) On the tonal side, the integration of old and new remains an art unto itself, merging existing and fresh material toward a tonal and musical result of complete unity. This is the particular skill of our tonal director Duane Prill, an Eastman-trained and practicing church organist, and voicer of some 35 years. Every flue pipe here has passed through his skilled hands, reviewed at length again in site finishing with Jonathan Ambrosino.
Projects of this magnitude take years to come to fruition, requiring individuals with the character, backbone, and sense of humor to overcome inevitable twists and turns. Throughout this project’s decade-long duration, we have had the pleasure of working with numerous individuals at the cathedral. Their goal was nothing less than an extraordinary instrument, not only for this active cathedral but also as a model for liturgy and music across the diocese.
Specifically, we thank director of music Mr. Jeremy Korba. From day one, Jeremy worked endlessly to optimize the outcome by uplifting the skills and talents of those around him. His signature phrase—“It’s all good”—sums up our experience. We also thank the Very Reverend Godfrey Mullen, OSB, former rector (currently rector at Cathedral of Saint Peter, Belleville, Illinois), and Father Alex Zenthoefer, current rector and vicar general of the Diocese of Evansville. Their support has been unwavering, with a wisdom and generosity of spirit even in the face of challenges associated with the cathedral renovation and subsequent pandemic.
The quiet and substantial generosity of Deacon David Allan Cook and his wife Virginia made this organ possible. They walked into the newly renovated cathedral and asked the simple question, “What else do you need?” Not only the organ but also an endowment for its future maintenance were funded solely by Mrs. Cook, as a gift to the cathedral and the community at large. It was especially sad when Deacon Cook passed away only while the organ was being installed. Our prayers go with Deacon Cook and to the entire Cook family.
For our firm, blessed with supportive clients over now decades, Saint Benedict’s has stood out for its sheer support, hospitality, and friendliness. They traveled the path with us from minor to major project and were gracious with the shift in schedule that change presented. When the three 53-foot tractor trailers showed up, scores of volunteers were ready to unload. When we needed to shift materials around the building, these same good people magically reappeared. Every midday we were fed plentifully, whether for a crew of two or fourteen. It’s easy to do one’s best work for such good people. To all the people of Saint Benedict’s, and to the glory of God, we dedicate our Opus 52.
Parsons Opus 52 will be dedicated by Nathan Laube on Saturday, February 8, 2025, at 7 p.m.
—Parsons Organ Builders
Cover photo: Mark Murry (Evansville Aerial)
GALLERY
Key action: electric-slider, with electric unit action. Stop action: electric
GREAT (Manual II, unenclosed) (* enclosed with Choir)
16′ Sub Principal (on façade) 61 pipes
16′ Gemshorn* (Choir)
8′ Open Diapason 61 pipes
8′ Principal (ext 16′) 12 pipes
8′ Harmonic Flute* 61 pipes
8′ Gamba* 61 pipes
8′ Gamba Celeste* 61 pipes
4′ Octave 61 pipes
4′ Principal (ext 16′) 12 pipes 4′ Spitz Flute* 61 pipes
2-2/3′ Twelfth 61 pipes
2′ Fifteenth 61 pipes
1-3/5′ Seventeenth 54 pipes
Mixture IV 244 pipes
Full Mixture IV* 244 pipes
16′ Trombone* 61 pipes
8′ Trumpet* 61 pipes
4′ Clarion* (ext 16′) 24 pipes
8′ Tuba* (Choir)
8′ Bombarde (ext Ped Bomb) 17 pipes
Chimes (digital)
SWELL (Manual III, expressive)
16′ Lieblich Gedeckt 61 pipes
8′ Open Diapason 61 pipes
8′ Open Flute 61 pipes
8′ Chimney Flute (ext 16′) 12 pipes
8′ Salicional 61 pipes
8′ Voix Celeste 61 pipes
8′ Flauto Dolce 61 pipes
8′ Flute Celeste 61 pipes
4′ Octave 61 pipes
4′ Traverse Flute 61 pipes
2′ Piccolo 61 pipes
Mixture III–IV 221 pipes
16′ Contra Fagotto 61 pipes
8′ Trompette 61 pipes
8′ Oboe 61 pipes
4′ Clarion 61 pipes
8′ Vox Humana 61 pipes
CHOIR (Manual I, expressive)
16′ Gemshorn 61 pipes
8′ Violin Diapason 61 pipes
8′ Bourdon 61 pipes
8′ Gemshorn (ext 16′) 12 pipes
8′ Gemshorn Celeste 61 pipes
4′ Fugara 61 pipes
4′ Gemshorn (ext 16′) 12 pipes
4′ Chimney Flute 61 pipes
2-2/3′ Nasard 61 pipes
2′ Principal 61 pipes
2′ Block Flute 61 pipes
1-3/5′ Tierce 54 pipes
1-1/3′ Larigot 61 pipes
1′ Sifflöte 61 pipes
Mixture III 183 Pipes
16′ Bass Clarinet (ext 8′) 12 pipes
8′ Tromba (Great)
8′ Clarinet 61 pipes
8′ English Horn 61 pipes
8′ Tuba 61 pipes
8′ Concert Flute (Nave)
8′ Pontifical Trumpet (Nave)
Cymbelstern (bells)
Harp (digital)
Celesta (digital)
Orchestral Bells (digital)
PEDAL (unenclosed)
32′ Contrebasse 32 pipes
32′ Bourdon (digital)
16′ Open Wood 32 pipes
16′ Principal (Great)
16′ Contrebasse (ext 32′) 12 pipes
16′ Bourdon 32 pipes
16′ Gemshorn (Choir)
16′ Lieblich Gedeckt (Swell)
8′ Octave (façade) 32 pipes
8′ Flûte (ext Open Wood) 12 pipes
8′ Bourdon (ext 16′) 12 pipes
8′ Gemshorn (Choir)
8′ Lieblich Gedeckt (Swell)
4′ Choral Bass (ext 8′) 12 pipes
4′ Flûte (ext. Open Wood) 12 pipes
32′ Contra Trombone 12 pipes (ext Great 16′)
16′ Bombarde 32 pipes
16′ Trombone (Great)
16′ Fagotto (Swell)
16′ Clarinet (Choir)
8′ Bombarde (ext 16′) 12 pipes
8′ Tromba (Great)
8′ Fagotto (Swell)
4′ Clarion (ext 16′) 12 pipes
8′ Tuba (Choir)
Chimes (digital)
NAVE
Key action: electric unit action.
Stop action: electric
Voice Analysis (all voices enclosed)
8 voices, 8 ranks, 560 pipes
16′ Bourdon 97 pipes
16′ Dulciana 85 pipes
8′ Diapason 73 pipes
8′ Concert Flute 61 pipes
8′ Unda Maris (TC) 61 pipes
22⁄3′ Nazard 61 pipes
8′ Flügelhorn 61 pipes
8′ Pontifical Trumpet 61 pipes
NAVE GREAT(Manual II)
8′ Diapason
8′ Concert Flute
8′ Chimney Flute
4′ Octave
4′ Chimney Flute
2′ Fifteenth
Mixture II
8′ Flügelhorn
8′ Pontifical Trumpet
NAVE SWELL (Manual III)
16′ Dulciana
8′ Chimney Flute
8′ Dulciana
8′ Unda Maris (TC)
4′ Octave
4′ Chimney Flute
4′ Dulciana
2-2/3′ Nazard
2′ Piccolo
8′ Flügelhorn
8′ Pontifical Trumpet
NAVE PEDAL
16′ Bourdon
16′ Dulciana
8′ Diapason
8′ Chimney Flute
4′ Octave
8′ Pontifical Trumpet
Accessories
General Tremulant
Nave Tremulant
Flexible Wind
Pedal Divide
All Swells to Swell
Crescendo On Nave Expression
Pedal Stops on Manual Combinations
Couplers
Intra-Manual
Gt to Gt 16
Gt Unison Off
Gt to Gt 4
Sw to Sw 16
Sw Unison Off
Sw to Sw 4
Ch to Ch 16
Ch Unison Off
Ch to Ch 4
Sw Nave Unison Off
Inter-Manual – Rocker tabs on nameboard
Sw to Gt 16
Sw to Gt 8
Sw to Gt 4
Ch to Gt 16
Ch to Gt 8
Ch to Gt 4
Nave Sw to Gt
Sw to Ch 16
Sw to Ch 8
Sw to Ch 4
Gt to Ch 8
Enc. Gt on Ch
Nave Sw on Ch
Ped to Ch
Ch to Sw 8
Sw to Ped 8
Sw to Ped 4
Gt to Ped 8
Ch to Ped 8
Ch to Ped 4
Nave Gt to Ped 8
Nave Sw to Ped 8
Ped Unison Off
Manual I-II Transfer
Manual compass: C–c 61 notes
Pedal compass: C–g 32 notes
Builder’s website: parsonsorgans.com
Cathedral website: www.saintbenedictcathedral.org