“Feast of the Gods,” the 282-page program book of the Boston Early Music Festival listed a bountiful smorgasbord of musical offerings from which each visitor to this biennial early music extravaganza could construct an individual menu. Stellar offerings at prime afternoon, evening, and late evening times carried the cachet (and financing) of the Festival proper; ancillary events, sponsored (but not paid for) by the BEMF organization, included a plethora of “fringe” concerts (I counted a total of 79 this year) as well as the displays comprising the exhibition, where much of the business of early music is conducted.
Inexpensive housing was available once again at the spartan, but convenient, “Little Building,” an Emerson College dormitory, ideally located on Boylston Street at Tremont, across from the Boston Common. The Cutler Majestic Theatre, home to BEMF opera productions, is just around the corner; the Radisson Hotel, site of the exhibition, only several blocks away. A congenial group of players and visitors met and conversed each morning at the bountiful breakfasts, included with the modest room charge.
“Fringe” concerts are often good indicators of the quality of early music performance around the country: a few of the groups selected from venues far distant from Boston were the Chicago-based Trio Settecento, with harpsichordist David Schrader; Colorado soloists from the Chamber Orchestra based in Denver, with harpsichordist Frank Nowell; and two groups from Texas: the University of North Texas Baroque Orchestra and Singers (Lyle Nordstrom, director), who presented two programs, and Fort Worth-based Texas Camerata, with rising (Lone-) star soprano Ava Pine, drew another capacity audience to its program at Emmanuel Church’s intimate, but resonant, neo-Gothic Lindsey Chapel, the site of many festival events.
After the Camerata performance on Wednesday afternoon I was eager to sample some music produced by others, starting with my first-ever attendance at a BEMF late-night program, German keyboardist Alexander Weimann’s “Apollonian” themed concert at New England Conservatory’s Jordan Hall. A technically difficult banality by the singularly named composer, “Tubel [London, 1789],” featured fast cross-hand passages at the harpsichord. Pachelbel’s Aria Sebaldina (Nürnberg, 1699), on a chamber organ, was played so percussively that the chiffy Gedeckt stop sounded more glockenspiel than flute. Mozart’s “Jupiter” Symphony, in Weimann’s transcription for fortepiano, was an amazing tour de force of notes, but left one thankful for the composer’s orchestration. While lyric passages worked beautifully on Paul McNulty’s splendid Anton Walter-styled fortepiano, fast and full episodes were amazing, but unsatisfying.
A short Thursday morning walk to the north end of the Common, past Freedom Trail Revolutionary-period costumed guides and their clients, led to the Paulist Center where clavichordist Judith Conrad played an hour of Music for the Holy Grail by Juan Bautista Cabanilles on a triple-fretted clavichord by Andreas Hermert (Berlin, 2003) after an instrument by Georg Woytzig (1689). The concert, a benefit for the Iraq Family Relief Fund, gave one the opportunity to acquire a “Clavichordists for World Peace” tee shirt. Who could resist? Ms. Conrad’s informal presentation of the Spanish master’s learned counterpoint, intermingled with kinetic dances appropriate to the Valencian ecclesiastical rubric for Corpus Christi celebrations (“twelve dances on the altar” required) delighted her capacity audience of 30 in the intimate third-floor library.
An overflow audience greeted Long Island’s Stony Brook Baroque Players in the Radisson exhibition room of The Harpsichord Clearing House. Arthur Haas’s student ensemble was this year’s winner of Early Music America’s grant for bringing a student early music ensemble to BEMF. In a program based on the Follia, 19 players showed their prowess in a variety of pieces by Uccellini, Marco da Gagliano, Dario Castello, Falconieri, Merula, and Locatelli. Mezzo-soprano Christine Free captured the text-driven moods and poignant heartbreak of Monteverdi’s Lamento d’Arianna. Nine players sizzled in Vivaldi’s Follia Variations (Sonata XII, RV 63), with fine continuo support from harpsichordist Tami Morse and baroque guitarist Jim Smith.
The superb BEMF Orchestra, out of the pit and on stage, played Thursday’s 8 o’clock sell-out concert in Jordan Hall. Presenting orchestral music from the operas of Jean-Philippe Rameau and a complete performance of The Judgment of Paris, a pastoral by John Eccles, the best baroque band in the land displayed its musical precision and exquisitely fine tuning. Under the leadership of festival co-directors Steven Stubbs and Paul O’Dette (playing baroque guitars and theorbos) and concert master Robert Mealey, the group didn’t miss a musical nuance. The ecstatic audience insisted on an encore, a reprise of the Tambourins from Rameau’s Dardanus.
The same orchestra starred in Jean-Baptiste Lully’s 1678 opera Psyché, receiving its North American premiere performances. Strong keyboard continuo realizations by Kristian Bezuidenhout (harpsichord) and Peter Sykes (harpsichord and organ), with the plucked strings of O’Dette and Stubbs, stellar strings and woodwinds, and most inventive percussion playing, including the “human” wind machine (a whistle) manipulated by Marie-Ange Petit anchored a spectacular production. Memorable stage moments, many accomplished by “deus ex machina” arrivals and departures, proved remarkably modern in concept (the solo singers wore seat belts as they were flown from or to the fly space above the stage). The sudden appearance of an adult L’Amour (replacing the young Cupid), through a double mirror, elicited a collective gasp, as did the evocative red lighting of the scenic underworld.
So many motives in Thomas Corneille’s opera libretto seemed to foreshadow works to come: the forbidden questioning of a lover’s name and a swan boat exit (Lohengrin); constructing a suitable palace for the gods (Rheingold); a vengeful queen raging in coloratura (The Magic Flute); or a required trip to Hades to rescue the beloved (Orfeo): even though hearing this work for the first time, one felt quite at home in operatic territory. A unit set served the action well: high hedge-ringed garden, fronted by a wrought-iron fence and ornate gates. The eight folding panels were opened and shut as needed by four footmen. Baroque gesture, appropriate choreography, vibrant costumes: I heard more than one listener remark that the “Festival had got this one absolutely right.”
Karina Gauvin stormed her way through the vocal histrionics of the jealous Venus. Carolyn Sampson was a sweet and vocally secure Psyché. Boy soprano Frederick Metzger negotiated the part of young Cupid with aplomb. Three black-clad Furies (Zachary Wilder, Jason McStoots, and Olivier Laquerre), in black wide-bustled gowns à la Mary Todd Lincoln, were appropriately demonic.
Earlier on Friday the organ took center stage in an all-day mini-festival, The Organ as a Mirror of Cultural Change. The morning sessions, at historic Old West Church, celebrated the 1971 C. B. Fisk organ (with its handsome Appleton case), in music of France at the time of Lully, with compositions by d’Anglebert, de Grigny, Chaumont, Dandrieu, Corrette, and both Louis and François Couperin. Two Lully overtures (transcribed from the operas Bellerophon and Cadmus) celebrated BEMF’s poster composer. The stylish players were Jan Willem Jansen and William Porter.
The afternoon sessions, Signor Buxtehudo and Monsieur Böhm, were held at First Lutheran Church, where the 2000 Richards, Fowkes & Co. organ, in a slightly more resonant space, served well in compositions by Dieterich Buxtehude and Georg Böhm, intersected by Kerala J. Snyder’s illuminating talk “What’s New in Buxtehude Scholarship?” Dr. Snyder relayed the good news that the post-1685 account books of St. Mary’s Church (Lübeck), previously missing, are now returned to Buxtehude’s city (after war wanderings), thus allowing more detailed study of expenses for such things as organ tuning and possible changes of keyboard temperament. Several new fragments of Buxtehude works, and even rediscovered compositions, have come to light, and she has had second thoughts on the possible identification of Buxtehude in the 1674 Hamburg painting by Johannes Voorhout, frontispiece to her important study Dieterich Buxtehude: Organist in Lübeck (New York: Schirmer Books, 1987)—all reasons enough to offer a revised, expanded edition (2007), now available from University of Rochester Press <www.urpress.com>.
The organ mini-festival programs were dedicated, fittingly enough, to the memory of Daniel Pinkham (1923–2006), Boston musician extraordinaire, who was memorialized in a program book tribute by BEMF board member, organist Lee Ridgway. Tribute was paid also to harpsichordist and author Howard Schott (1923–2005) in graceful words from Paul Cienniwa.
On the instrument front there was much excitement generated by a new double-manual harpsichord built by Zuckermann Harpsichords International, based on the 1642 Hans Moermans, formerly in the collection of the late Rodger Mirrey (London), now in the Russell Collection (Edinburgh). The design, to drawings by R. P. Hale with Peter Watchorn’s input and musical finishing, provides a replica of an instrument that may be the earliest expressive double harpsichord to survive. (For more complete information, see
<http://zhi.net/instr/moermans.shtml>.)
The Harpsichord Clearing House (Glenn Guittari and Howard Wagner) showed a variety of instruments in their spacious quarters at the Radisson (the Dartmouth Room), where daily concerts also took place. Eagerly anticipated (at least by some of us) is the outcome of the bidding for HCH’s desirable antique offering, a 1907 Dolmetsch-Chickering clavichord, held for sale at this year’s festival. Bids were to begin at $25,000.
On a warming, sunny Saturday morning a leisurely stroll to the Goethe Center put me there too late to hear the program: Handel’s Opera—His immortal songs without words, and some other pieces by his musicians—comprising 18th-century arrangements of popular Handel overtures and arias for recorders and harpsichord. It was a cleverly-contrived playlist, and the performers, “Musical Playground,” Martina Bley (recorders) and Jörg Jacobi (harpsichord), otherwise were to be seen at the Exhibition as purveyors of their early music publications from “edition baroque” (Bremen).
Too soon it was time to head for Logan Airport, where takeoff was delayed until there was some hope of landing in stormy Dallas. Waiting, however, gave time to reflect on Boston’s unique contributions to the world of early music, and to realize again that it is the place to be during festival week in June of odd-numbered years.
